Decision Summary

Alternatives:
A1a - Carpet in Offices More Info
[X]
Alternative: A1a - Carpet in Offices
Additional information
ADD $10,780
*Designer Identified Essential to Acoustical Function of Space
A1b - Carpet in Open Conference More Info
[X]
Alternative: A1b - Carpet in Open Conference
Additional information
ADD $941
*Designer Identified Essential to Acoustical Function of Space
A1c - Carpet in Collaboration Space More Info
[X]
Alternative: A1c - Carpet in Collaboration Space
Additional information
ADD $2,919
*Designer Identified Essential to Acoustical Function of Space
A2 - Tile Floors More Info
[X]
Alternative: A2 - Tile Floors
Additional information
ADD $3,818
A3a - Acoustical Ceiling in Flex Space More Info
[X]
Alternative: A3a - Acoustical Ceiling in Flex Space
Additional information
ADD $18,919
*Designer Identified Essential to Acoustical Function of Space
A3b - Acoustical Ceiling in PhD Space More Info
[X]
Alternative: A3b - Acoustical Ceiling in PhD Space
Additional information
ADD $6,166
*Designer Identified Essential to Acoustical Function of Space
A4 - Energy Dashboard More Info
[X]
Alternative: A4 - Energy Dashboard
Additional information
Evergreen awaiting JCI Price
A5 - Visual Display Boards More Info
[X]
Alternative: A5 - Visual Display Boards
Additional information
Evergreen Needs Specifications
A6 - Sidewalk & Courtyard Replacement More Info
[X]
Alternative: A6 - Sidewalk & Courtyard Replacement
Additional information
ADD $20,964
VE24 - Carbon Steel Picket Rail in lieu of Glass Rail @ Stair More Info
[X]
Alternative: VE24 - Carbon Steel Picket Rail in lieu of Glass Rail @ Stair
Additional information
ADD $20,996
*Designer Identified Early Action Item
VE26 - Delete Drywall Soffits/Projections @ Offices More Info
[X]
Alternative: VE26 - Delete Drywall Soffits/Projections @ Offices
Additional information
ADD $4,795
*Designer Suggested Priority Add-Back - Lighting/Daylighting #1 Programmatic Objective
(Light Shelves & Obscuring Mechanical from View)
VE27 - Delete Drywall Soffits/Projections @ Corridors & Conf Rms More Info
[X]
Alternative: VE27 - Delete Drywall Soffits/Projections @ Corridors & Conf Rms
Additional information
ADD $2,503
*Designer Suggested Priority Add-Back - Lighting/Daylighting #1 Programmatic Objective
(Light Shelves & Obscuring Mechanical from View)
VE28 - Install 2'x2' Acoustical Ceilings in lieu of Tectum Panels More Info
[X]
Alternative: VE28 - Install 2'x2' Acoustical Ceilings in lieu of Tectum Panels
Additional information
Tectum Panels attached to Structure
ADD $6,129
VE32 - Delete Skylights in their Entirety
Winner
More Info
[X]
Alternative: VE32 - Delete Skylights in their Entirety
Additional information
ADD $9,466
*Designer Suggested Priority Add-Back - Lighting/Daylighting #1 Programmatic Objective
VE55 - Delete Exterior Light Fixtures More Info
[X]
Alternative: VE55 - Delete Exterior Light Fixtures
Additional information
ADD $29,313
VE56 - Delete Exterior Light Fixture Rough-In More Info
[X]
Alternative: VE56 - Delete Exterior Light Fixture Rough-In
Additional information
ADD $7,012
*Designer Identified Early Action Item
VE63b - Remove New Concrete East of Building More Info
[X]
Alternative: VE63b - Remove New Concrete East of Building
Additional information
Excludes Construction Related Patch & Repair
ADD $12,799
VE64b - Remove Benches More Info
[X]
Alternative: VE64b - Remove Benches
Additional information
ADD $3,054
VE15 - Delete Rolling Partition Support Steel More Info
[X]
Alternative: VE15 - Delete Rolling Partition Support Steel
Additional information
ADD $2,576
*Designer Suggested Priority Add-Back - Main RFP Collaboration Objective
VE18b - Utilize comparable system to Kawneer 1600 Wall System 1 More Info
[X]
Alternative: VE18b - Utilize comparable system to Kawneer 1600 Wall System 1
Additional information
Kawneer 1600 Wall System 1 with captured verticals & horizontals
in lieu of 4-sided SSG Curtainwall System with Solarban 60 Glass

ADD $8,844
*Designer Suggested Priority Add-Back - Necessary to Meet Defined High-Ranking Programmatic Objective of Project to translate "Technical Sophistication"
VE21b - Keep existing brick cavity wall on North & South Elevations More Info
[X]
Alternative: VE21b - Keep existing brick cavity wall on North & South Elevations
Additional information
ADD $22,229
*Designer Suggested Priority Add-Back - to provide "Darker Brick" requested by PDC
Brick Stain on N/S Elevations More Info
[X]
Alternative: Brick Stain on N/S Elevations
Additional information
Total Value:
195.40
87.20
87.20
87.20
0.00
134.40
134.40
66.00
79.00
0.00
64.00
155.00
155.00
121.60
195.40
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
175.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
Values:
0.0
Acoustics More Info
3 -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
57.60
Thermal Comfort More Info
2 -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
29.60
Acoustics More Info
3 -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
57.60
Thermal Comfort More Info
2 -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
29.60
Acoustics More Info
3 -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
57.60
Thermal Comfort More Info
2 -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
29.60
Acoustics More Info
5 -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
96.00
Interior Architecture More Info
3 -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
38.40
Acoustics More Info
5 -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
96.00
Interior Architecture More Info
3 -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
38.40
Energy Efficiency More Info
5 -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
66.00
Collaborative Learning More Info
5 -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
79.00
Interior Architecture More Info
5 -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
64.00
Lighting/Daylighting More Info
5 -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
91.00
Interior Architecture More Info
5 -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
64.00
Lighting/Daylighting More Info
5 -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
91.00
Interior Architecture More Info
5 -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
64.00
Acoustics More Info
3 -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
57.60
Interior Architecture More Info
5 -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
64.00
Lighting/Daylighting More Info
5 -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
91.00
Interior Architecture More Info
3 -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
38.40
Energy Efficiency More Info
5 -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
66.00
Collaborative Learning More Info
5 -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
79.00
Acoustics More Info
5 -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
96.00
0.00
Goal: Acoustics
Alternative: A1a - Carpet in Offices
Stakeholder Stakeholder Weight Goal Weight Impact Value
Howard Wertheimer 100% 100% 60.00 60.00
Daniel Castro 100% 100% 60.00 60.00
David Yocum 100% 100% 60.00 60.00
Hunter Letts 100% 100% 60.00 60.00
Gary Jelin 100% 80% 60.00 48.00
Total Value 288.00
Number Valid Stakeholders 5
Average Value 57.60
Goal: Thermal Comfort
Alternative: A1a - Carpet in Offices
Stakeholder Stakeholder Weight Goal Weight Impact Value
Howard Wertheimer 100% 100% 40.00 40.00
Daniel Castro 100% 75% 40.00 30.00
David Yocum 100% 10% 40.00 4.00
Hunter Letts 100% 100% 40.00 40.00
Gary Jelin 100% 85% 40.00 34.00
Total Value 148.00
Number Valid Stakeholders 5
Average Value 29.60
Goal: Acoustics
Alternative: A1b - Carpet in Open Conference
Stakeholder Stakeholder Weight Goal Weight Impact Value
Howard Wertheimer 100% 100% 60.00 60.00
Daniel Castro 100% 100% 60.00 60.00
David Yocum 100% 100% 60.00 60.00
Hunter Letts 100% 100% 60.00 60.00
Gary Jelin 100% 80% 60.00 48.00
Total Value 288.00
Number Valid Stakeholders 5
Average Value 57.60
Goal: Thermal Comfort
Alternative: A1b - Carpet in Open Conference
Stakeholder Stakeholder Weight Goal Weight Impact Value
Howard Wertheimer 100% 100% 40.00 40.00
Daniel Castro 100% 75% 40.00 30.00
David Yocum 100% 10% 40.00 4.00
Hunter Letts 100% 100% 40.00 40.00
Gary Jelin 100% 85% 40.00 34.00
Total Value 148.00
Number Valid Stakeholders 5
Average Value 29.60
Goal: Acoustics
Alternative: A1c - Carpet in Collaboration Space
Stakeholder Stakeholder Weight Goal Weight Impact Value
Howard Wertheimer 100% 100% 60.00 60.00
Daniel Castro 100% 100% 60.00 60.00
David Yocum 100% 100% 60.00 60.00
Hunter Letts 100% 100% 60.00 60.00
Gary Jelin 100% 80% 60.00 48.00
Total Value 288.00
Number Valid Stakeholders 5
Average Value 57.60
Goal: Thermal Comfort
Alternative: A1c - Carpet in Collaboration Space
Stakeholder Stakeholder Weight Goal Weight Impact Value
Howard Wertheimer 100% 100% 40.00 40.00
Daniel Castro 100% 75% 40.00 30.00
David Yocum 100% 10% 40.00 4.00
Hunter Letts 100% 100% 40.00 40.00
Gary Jelin 100% 85% 40.00 34.00
Total Value 148.00
Number Valid Stakeholders 5
Average Value 29.60
Goal: Acoustics
Alternative: A3a - Acoustical Ceiling in Flex Space
Stakeholder Stakeholder Weight Goal Weight Impact Value
Howard Wertheimer 100% 100% 100.00 100.00
Daniel Castro 100% 100% 100.00 100.00
David Yocum 100% 100% 100.00 100.00
Hunter Letts 100% 100% 100.00 100.00
Gary Jelin 100% 80% 100.00 80.00
Total Value 480.00
Number Valid Stakeholders 5
Average Value 96.00
Goal: Interior Architecture
Alternative: A3a - Acoustical Ceiling in Flex Space
Stakeholder Stakeholder Weight Goal Weight Impact Value
Howard Wertheimer 100% 100% 60.00 60.00
Daniel Castro 100% 10% 60.00 6.00
David Yocum 100% 100% 60.00 60.00
Hunter Letts 100% 50% 60.00 30.00
Gary Jelin 100% 60% 60.00 36.00
Total Value 192.00
Number Valid Stakeholders 5
Average Value 38.40
Goal: Acoustics
Alternative: A3b - Acoustical Ceiling in PhD Space
Stakeholder Stakeholder Weight Goal Weight Impact Value
Howard Wertheimer 100% 100% 100.00 100.00
Daniel Castro 100% 100% 100.00 100.00
David Yocum 100% 100% 100.00 100.00
Hunter Letts 100% 100% 100.00 100.00
Gary Jelin 100% 80% 100.00 80.00
Total Value 480.00
Number Valid Stakeholders 5
Average Value 96.00
Goal: Interior Architecture
Alternative: A3b - Acoustical Ceiling in PhD Space
Stakeholder Stakeholder Weight Goal Weight Impact Value
Howard Wertheimer 100% 100% 60.00 60.00
Daniel Castro 100% 10% 60.00 6.00
David Yocum 100% 100% 60.00 60.00
Hunter Letts 100% 50% 60.00 30.00
Gary Jelin 100% 60% 60.00 36.00
Total Value 192.00
Number Valid Stakeholders 5
Average Value 38.40
Goal: Energy Efficiency
Alternative: A4 - Energy Dashboard
Stakeholder Stakeholder Weight Goal Weight Impact Value
Howard Wertheimer 100% 85% 100.00 85.00
Daniel Castro 100% 50% 100.00 50.00
David Yocum 100% 10% 100.00 10.00
Hunter Letts 100% 100% 100.00 100.00
Gary Jelin 100% 85% 100.00 85.00
Total Value 330.00
Number Valid Stakeholders 5
Average Value 66.00
Goal: Collaborative Learning
Alternative: A5 - Visual Display Boards
Stakeholder Stakeholder Weight Goal Weight Impact Value
Howard Wertheimer 100% 100% 100.00 100.00
Daniel Castro 100% 100% 100.00 100.00
David Yocum 100% 10% 100.00 10.00
Hunter Letts 100% 100% 100.00 100.00
Gary Jelin 100% 85% 100.00 85.00
Total Value 395.00
Number Valid Stakeholders 5
Average Value 79.00
Goal: Interior Architecture
Alternative: VE24 - Carbon Steel Picket Rail in lieu of Glass Rail @ Stair
Stakeholder Stakeholder Weight Goal Weight Impact Value
Howard Wertheimer 100% 100% 100.00 100.00
Daniel Castro 100% 10% 100.00 10.00
David Yocum 100% 100% 100.00 100.00
Hunter Letts 100% 50% 100.00 50.00
Gary Jelin 100% 60% 100.00 60.00
Total Value 320.00
Number Valid Stakeholders 5
Average Value 64.00
Goal: Lighting/Daylighting
Alternative: VE26 - Delete Drywall Soffits/Projections @ Offices
Stakeholder Stakeholder Weight Goal Weight Impact Value
Howard Wertheimer 100% 100% 100.00 100.00
Daniel Castro 100% 75% 100.00 75.00
David Yocum 100% 100% 100.00 100.00
Hunter Letts 100% 100% 100.00 100.00
Gary Jelin 100% 80% 100.00 80.00
Total Value 455.00
Number Valid Stakeholders 5
Average Value 91.00
Goal: Interior Architecture
Alternative: VE26 - Delete Drywall Soffits/Projections @ Offices
Stakeholder Stakeholder Weight Goal Weight Impact Value
Howard Wertheimer 100% 100% 100.00 100.00
Daniel Castro 100% 10% 100.00 10.00
David Yocum 100% 100% 100.00 100.00
Hunter Letts 100% 50% 100.00 50.00
Gary Jelin 100% 60% 100.00 60.00
Total Value 320.00
Number Valid Stakeholders 5
Average Value 64.00
Goal: Lighting/Daylighting
Alternative: VE27 - Delete Drywall Soffits/Projections @ Corridors & Conf Rms
Stakeholder Stakeholder Weight Goal Weight Impact Value
Howard Wertheimer 100% 100% 100.00 100.00
Daniel Castro 100% 75% 100.00 75.00
David Yocum 100% 100% 100.00 100.00
Hunter Letts 100% 100% 100.00 100.00
Gary Jelin 100% 80% 100.00 80.00
Total Value 455.00
Number Valid Stakeholders 5
Average Value 91.00
Goal: Interior Architecture
Alternative: VE27 - Delete Drywall Soffits/Projections @ Corridors & Conf Rms
Stakeholder Stakeholder Weight Goal Weight Impact Value
Howard Wertheimer 100% 100% 100.00 100.00
Daniel Castro 100% 10% 100.00 10.00
David Yocum 100% 100% 100.00 100.00
Hunter Letts 100% 50% 100.00 50.00
Gary Jelin 100% 60% 100.00 60.00
Total Value 320.00
Number Valid Stakeholders 5
Average Value 64.00
Goal: Acoustics
Alternative: VE28 - Install 2'x2' Acoustical Ceilings in lieu of Tectum Panels
Stakeholder Stakeholder Weight Goal Weight Impact Value
Howard Wertheimer 100% 100% 60.00 60.00
Daniel Castro 100% 100% 60.00 60.00
David Yocum 100% 100% 60.00 60.00
Hunter Letts 100% 100% 60.00 60.00
Gary Jelin 100% 80% 60.00 48.00
Total Value 288.00
Number Valid Stakeholders 5
Average Value 57.60
Goal: Interior Architecture
Alternative: VE28 - Install 2'x2' Acoustical Ceilings in lieu of Tectum Panels
Stakeholder Stakeholder Weight Goal Weight Impact Value
Howard Wertheimer 100% 100% 100.00 100.00
Daniel Castro 100% 10% 100.00 10.00
David Yocum 100% 100% 100.00 100.00
Hunter Letts 100% 50% 100.00 50.00
Gary Jelin 100% 60% 100.00 60.00
Total Value 320.00
Number Valid Stakeholders 5
Average Value 64.00
Goal: Lighting/Daylighting
Alternative: VE32 - Delete Skylights in their Entirety
Stakeholder Stakeholder Weight Goal Weight Impact Value
Howard Wertheimer 100% 100% 100.00 100.00
Daniel Castro 100% 75% 100.00 75.00
David Yocum 100% 100% 100.00 100.00
Hunter Letts 100% 100% 100.00 100.00
Gary Jelin 100% 80% 100.00 80.00
Total Value 455.00
Number Valid Stakeholders 5
Average Value 91.00
Goal: Interior Architecture
Alternative: VE32 - Delete Skylights in their Entirety
Stakeholder Stakeholder Weight Goal Weight Impact Value
Howard Wertheimer 100% 100% 60.00 60.00
Daniel Castro 100% 10% 60.00 6.00
David Yocum 100% 100% 60.00 60.00
Hunter Letts 100% 50% 60.00 30.00
Gary Jelin 100% 60% 60.00 36.00
Total Value 192.00
Number Valid Stakeholders 5
Average Value 38.40
Goal: Energy Efficiency
Alternative: VE32 - Delete Skylights in their Entirety
Stakeholder Stakeholder Weight Goal Weight Impact Value
Howard Wertheimer 100% 85% 100.00 85.00
Daniel Castro 100% 50% 100.00 50.00
David Yocum 100% 10% 100.00 10.00
Hunter Letts 100% 100% 100.00 100.00
Gary Jelin 100% 85% 100.00 85.00
Total Value 330.00
Number Valid Stakeholders 5
Average Value 66.00
Goal: Collaborative Learning
Alternative: VE15 - Delete Rolling Partition Support Steel
Stakeholder Stakeholder Weight Goal Weight Impact Value
Howard Wertheimer 100% 100% 100.00 100.00
Daniel Castro 100% 100% 100.00 100.00
David Yocum 100% 10% 100.00 10.00
Hunter Letts 100% 100% 100.00 100.00
Gary Jelin 100% 85% 100.00 85.00
Total Value 395.00
Number Valid Stakeholders 5
Average Value 79.00
Goal: Acoustics
Alternative: VE15 - Delete Rolling Partition Support Steel
Stakeholder Stakeholder Weight Goal Weight Impact Value
Howard Wertheimer 100% 100% 100.00 100.00
Daniel Castro 100% 100% 100.00 100.00
David Yocum 100% 100% 100.00 100.00
Hunter Letts 100% 100% 100.00 100.00
Gary Jelin 100% 80% 100.00 80.00
Total Value 480.00
Number Valid Stakeholders 5
Average Value 96.00
Stakeholders
Daniel Castro
Howard Wertheimer
Gary Jelin
David Yocum
Hunter Letts
Designers
John Haymaker
Jennifer Disotell
David Yocum
Hunter Letts

Value by Goal

  • Alternatives
    • [X]
      Alternative: A1a - Carpet in Offices
      Additional information
      ADD $10,780
      *Designer Identified Essential to Acoustical Function of Space
      A1a - Carpet in Offices
    • [X]
      Alternative: A1b - Carpet in Open Conference
      Additional information
      ADD $941
      *Designer Identified Essential to Acoustical Function of Space
      A1b - Carpet in Open Conference
    • [X]
      Alternative: A1c - Carpet in Collaboration Space
      Additional information
      ADD $2,919
      *Designer Identified Essential to Acoustical Function of Space
      A1c - Carpet in Collaboration Space
    • [X]
      Alternative: A2 - Tile Floors
      Additional information
      ADD $3,818
      A2 - Tile Floors
    • [X]
      Alternative: A3a - Acoustical Ceiling in Flex Space
      Additional information
      ADD $18,919
      *Designer Identified Essential to Acoustical Function of Space
      A3a - Acoustical Ceiling in Flex Space
    • [X]
      Alternative: A3b - Acoustical Ceiling in PhD Space
      Additional information
      ADD $6,166
      *Designer Identified Essential to Acoustical Function of Space
      A3b - Acoustical Ceiling in PhD Space
    • [X]
      Alternative: A4 - Energy Dashboard
      Additional information
      Evergreen awaiting JCI Price
      A4 - Energy Dashboard
    • [X]
      Alternative: A5 - Visual Display Boards
      Additional information
      Evergreen Needs Specifications
      A5 - Visual Display Boards
    • [X]
      Alternative: A6 - Sidewalk & Courtyard Replacement
      Additional information
      ADD $20,964
      A6 - Sidewalk & Courtyard Replacement
    • [X]
      Alternative: VE24 - Carbon Steel Picket Rail in lieu of Glass Rail @ Stair
      Additional information
      ADD $20,996
      *Designer Identified Early Action Item
      VE24 - Carbon Steel Picket Rail in lieu of Glass Rail @ Stair
    • [X]
      Alternative: VE26 - Delete Drywall Soffits/Projections @ Offices
      Additional information
      ADD $4,795
      *Designer Suggested Priority Add-Back - Lighting/Daylighting #1 Programmatic Objective
      (Light Shelves & Obscuring Mechanical from View)
      VE26 - Delete Drywall Soffits/Projections @ Offices
    • [X]
      Alternative: VE27 - Delete Drywall Soffits/Projections @ Corridors & Conf Rms
      Additional information
      ADD $2,503
      *Designer Suggested Priority Add-Back - Lighting/Daylighting #1 Programmatic Objective
      (Light Shelves & Obscuring Mechanical from View)
      VE27 - Delete Drywall Soffits/Projections @ Corridors & Conf Rms
    • [X]
      Alternative: VE28 - Install 2'x2' Acoustical Ceilings in lieu of Tectum Panels
      Additional information
      Tectum Panels attached to Structure
      ADD $6,129
      VE28 - Install 2'x2' Acoustical Ceilings in lieu of Tectum Panels
    • [X]
      Alternative: VE32 - Delete Skylights in their Entirety
      Additional information
      ADD $9,466
      *Designer Suggested Priority Add-Back - Lighting/Daylighting #1 Programmatic Objective
      VE32 - Delete Skylights in their Entirety
    • [X]
      Alternative: VE55 - Delete Exterior Light Fixtures
      Additional information
      ADD $29,313
      VE55 - Delete Exterior Light Fixtures
    • [X]
      Alternative: VE56 - Delete Exterior Light Fixture Rough-In
      Additional information
      ADD $7,012
      *Designer Identified Early Action Item
      VE56 - Delete Exterior Light Fixture Rough-In
    • [X]
      Alternative: VE63b - Remove New Concrete East of Building
      Additional information
      Excludes Construction Related Patch & Repair
      ADD $12,799
      VE63b - Remove New Concrete East of Building
    • [X]
      Alternative: VE64b - Remove Benches
      Additional information
      ADD $3,054
      VE64b - Remove Benches
    • [X]
      Alternative: VE15 - Delete Rolling Partition Support Steel
      Additional information
      ADD $2,576
      *Designer Suggested Priority Add-Back - Main RFP Collaboration Objective
      VE15 - Delete Rolling Partition Support Steel
    • [X]
      Alternative: VE18b - Utilize comparable system to Kawneer 1600 Wall System 1
      Additional information
      Kawneer 1600 Wall System 1 with captured verticals & horizontals
      in lieu of 4-sided SSG Curtainwall System with Solarban 60 Glass

      ADD $8,844
      *Designer Suggested Priority Add-Back - Necessary to Meet Defined High-Ranking Programmatic Objective of Project to translate "Technical Sophistication"
      VE18b - Utilize comparable system to Kawneer 1600 Wall System 1
    • [X]
      Alternative: VE21b - Keep existing brick cavity wall on North & South Elevations
      Additional information
      ADD $22,229
      *Designer Suggested Priority Add-Back - to provide "Darker Brick" requested by PDC
      VE21b - Keep existing brick cavity wall on North & South Elevations
    • [X]
      Alternative: Brick Stain on N/S Elevations
      Additional information
      Brick Stain on N/S Elevations
  • Legend
    Objectives Select All Select All Leaf Objectives Unselect All
    • [X]
      Goal: Collaborative Learning
      Unit
      -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
      Criterion
      [Note: Priority #4 per Programmatic Objectives Document.]
      Collaborative Learning
    • [X]
      Goal: Lighting/Daylighting
      Unit
      -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
      Criterion
      Applies to both shared daylighting from exterior, and quality of interior light generally. [Note: Priority #1 per Programmatic Objectives Document.]
      Lighting/Daylighting
    • [X]
      Goal: Acoustics
      Unit
      -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
      Criterion
      Ambient noise absorption, speech intelligibility, and privacy.
      Acoustics
    • [X]
      Goal: Thermal Comfort
      Unit
      -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
      Criterion
      Thermal Comfort
    • [X]
      Goal: Exterior Architecture
      Unit
      -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
      Criterion
      General aspects of exterior appearance and function. [Note: Priority #2 per Programmatic Objectives Document.]
      Exterior Architecture
    • [X]
      Goal: Interior Architecture
      Unit
      -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
      Criterion
      General aspects of interior appearance and function. [Note: Priority #6 per Programmatic Objectives Document.]
      Interior Architecture
    • [X]
      Goal: Energy Efficiency
      Unit
      -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
      Criterion
      Energy Efficiency
  • Stakeholders Select All Unselect All
    • CPSM
      • Howard Wertheimer
    • D&C
      • Gary Jelin
    • BC
      • Daniel Castro
    • BLDGS
      • David Yocum
    • Evergreen
      • Hunter Letts

Goal Weights

Stakeholder Name:
Goal Weight:
    • Goals
      • %
        Collaborative Learning
      • %
        Lighting/Daylighting
      • %
        Acoustics
      • %
        Thermal Comfort
      • %
        Exterior Architecture
      • %
        Interior Architecture
      • %
        Energy Efficiency

Stakeholder Weights

Legend
  • Stakeholders
    • CPSM
      • %
        Name: Howard Wertheimer
        Email: howard.wertheimer@spaceplan.gatech.edu
        Howard Wertheimer
    • D&C
      • %
        Name: Gary Jelin
        Email: gary.jelin@facilities.gatech.edu
        Gary Jelin
    • BC
      • %
        Name: Daniel Castro
        Email: daniel.castro@coa.gatech.edu
        Daniel Castro
    • BLDGS
      • %
        Name: David Yocum
        Email: dy@bldgs.org
        David Yocum
    • Evergreen
      • %
        Name: Hunter Letts
        Email: hletts@evergreencorp.com
        Hunter Letts

Impact

  • A1a - Carpet in Offices
    A1a - Carpet in Offices
    [X]
    Alternative: A1a - Carpet in Offices
    Additional information
    ADD $10,780
    *Designer Identified Essential to Acoustical Function of Space
  • A1b - Carpet in Open Conference
    A1b - Carpet in Open Conference
    [X]
    Alternative: A1b - Carpet in Open Conference
    Additional information
    ADD $941
    *Designer Identified Essential to Acoustical Function of Space
  • A1c - Carpet in Collaboration Space
    A1c - Carpet in Collaboration Space
    [X]
    Alternative: A1c - Carpet in Collaboration Space
    Additional information
    ADD $2,919
    *Designer Identified Essential to Acoustical Function of Space
  • A2 - Tile Floors
    A2 - Tile Floors
    [X]
    Alternative: A2 - Tile Floors
    Additional information
    ADD $3,818
  • A3a - Acoustical Ceiling in Flex Space
    A3a - Acoustical Ceiling in Flex Space
    [X]
    Alternative: A3a - Acoustical Ceiling in Flex Space
    Additional information
    ADD $18,919
    *Designer Identified Essential to Acoustical Function of Space
  • A3b - Acoustical Ceiling in PhD Space
    A3b - Acoustical Ceiling in PhD Space
    [X]
    Alternative: A3b - Acoustical Ceiling in PhD Space
    Additional information
    ADD $6,166
    *Designer Identified Essential to Acoustical Function of Space
  • A4 - Energy Dashboard
    A4 - Energy Dashboard
    [X]
    Alternative: A4 - Energy Dashboard
    Additional information
    Evergreen awaiting JCI Price
  • A5 - Visual Display Boards
    A5 - Visual Display Boards
    [X]
    Alternative: A5 - Visual Display Boards
    Additional information
    Evergreen Needs Specifications
  • A6 - Sidewalk & Courtyard Replacement
    A6 - Sidewalk & Courtyard Replacement
    [X]
    Alternative: A6 - Sidewalk & Courtyard Replacement
    Additional information
    ADD $20,964
  • VE24 - Carbon Steel Picket Rail in lieu of Glass Rail @ Stair
    VE24 - Carbon Steel Picket Rail in lieu of Glass Rail @ Stair
    [X]
    Alternative: VE24 - Carbon Steel Picket Rail in lieu of Glass Rail @ Stair
    Additional information
    ADD $20,996
    *Designer Identified Early Action Item
  • VE26 - Delete Drywall Soffits/Projections @ Offices
    VE26 - Delete Drywall Soffits/Projections @ Offices
    [X]
    Alternative: VE26 - Delete Drywall Soffits/Projections @ Offices
    Additional information
    ADD $4,795
    *Designer Suggested Priority Add-Back - Lighting/Daylighting #1 Programmatic Objective
    (Light Shelves & Obscuring Mechanical from View)
  • VE27 - Delete Drywall Soffits/Projections @ Corridors & Conf Rms
    VE27 - Delete Drywall Soffits/Projections @ Corridors & Conf Rms
    [X]
    Alternative: VE27 - Delete Drywall Soffits/Projections @ Corridors & Conf Rms
    Additional information
    ADD $2,503
    *Designer Suggested Priority Add-Back - Lighting/Daylighting #1 Programmatic Objective
    (Light Shelves & Obscuring Mechanical from View)
  • VE28 - Install 2'x2' Acoustical Ceilings in lieu of Tectum Panels
    VE28 - Install 2'x2' Acoustical Ceilings in lieu of Tectum Panels
    [X]
    Alternative: VE28 - Install 2'x2' Acoustical Ceilings in lieu of Tectum Panels
    Additional information
    Tectum Panels attached to Structure
    ADD $6,129
  • VE32 - Delete Skylights in their Entirety
    VE32 - Delete Skylights in their Entirety
    [X]
    Alternative: VE32 - Delete Skylights in their Entirety
    Additional information
    ADD $9,466
    *Designer Suggested Priority Add-Back - Lighting/Daylighting #1 Programmatic Objective
  • VE55 - Delete Exterior Light Fixtures
    VE55 - Delete Exterior Light Fixtures
    [X]
    Alternative: VE55 - Delete Exterior Light Fixtures
    Additional information
    ADD $29,313
  • VE56 - Delete Exterior Light Fixture Rough-In
    VE56 - Delete Exterior Light Fixture Rough-In
    [X]
    Alternative: VE56 - Delete Exterior Light Fixture Rough-In
    Additional information
    ADD $7,012
    *Designer Identified Early Action Item
  • VE63b - Remove New Concrete East of Building
    VE63b - Remove New Concrete East of Building
    [X]
    Alternative: VE63b - Remove New Concrete East of Building
    Additional information
    Excludes Construction Related Patch & Repair
    ADD $12,799
  • VE64b - Remove Benches
    VE64b - Remove Benches
    [X]
    Alternative: VE64b - Remove Benches
    Additional information
    ADD $3,054
  • VE15 - Delete Rolling Partition Support Steel
    VE15 - Delete Rolling Partition Support Steel
    [X]
    Alternative: VE15 - Delete Rolling Partition Support Steel
    Additional information
    ADD $2,576
    *Designer Suggested Priority Add-Back - Main RFP Collaboration Objective
  • VE18b - Utilize comparable system to Kawneer 1600 Wall System 1
    VE18b - Utilize comparable system to Kawneer 1600 Wall System 1
    [X]
    Alternative: VE18b - Utilize comparable system to Kawneer 1600 Wall System 1
    Additional information
    Kawneer 1600 Wall System 1 with captured verticals & horizontals
    in lieu of 4-sided SSG Curtainwall System with Solarban 60 Glass

    ADD $8,844
    *Designer Suggested Priority Add-Back - Necessary to Meet Defined High-Ranking Programmatic Objective of Project to translate "Technical Sophistication"
  • VE21b - Keep existing brick cavity wall on North & South Elevations
    VE21b - Keep existing brick cavity wall on North & South Elevations
    [X]
    Alternative: VE21b - Keep existing brick cavity wall on North & South Elevations
    Additional information
    ADD $22,229
    *Designer Suggested Priority Add-Back - to provide "Darker Brick" requested by PDC
  • Brick Stain on N/S Elevations
    Brick Stain on N/S Elevations
    [X]
    Alternative: Brick Stain on N/S Elevations
    Additional information
  • Goals
    • Designer
      [X]
      Goal: Collaborative Learning
      Unit
      -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
      Criterion
      [Note: Priority #4 per Programmatic Objectives Document.]
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Collaborative Learning
      Alternative:A1a - Carpet in Offices
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Collaborative Learning
      Alternative:A1b - Carpet in Open Conference
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Collaborative Learning
      Alternative:A1c - Carpet in Collaboration Space
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Collaborative Learning
      Alternative:A2 - Tile Floors
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Collaborative Learning
      Alternative:A3a - Acoustical Ceiling in Flex Space
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Collaborative Learning
      Alternative:A3b - Acoustical Ceiling in PhD Space
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Collaborative Learning
      Alternative:A4 - Energy Dashboard
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      5
      5.00
      100.00
      Goal:Collaborative Learning
      Alternative:A5 - Visual Display Boards
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Collaborative Learning
      Alternative:A6 - Sidewalk & Courtyard Replacement
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Collaborative Learning
      Alternative:VE24 - Carbon Steel Picket Rail in lieu of Glass Rail @ Stair
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Collaborative Learning
      Alternative:VE26 - Delete Drywall Soffits/Projections @ Offices
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Collaborative Learning
      Alternative:VE27 - Delete Drywall Soffits/Projections @ Corridors & Conf Rms
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Collaborative Learning
      Alternative:VE28 - Install 2'x2' Acoustical Ceilings in lieu of Tectum Panels
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Collaborative Learning
      Alternative:VE32 - Delete Skylights in their Entirety
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Collaborative Learning
      Alternative:VE55 - Delete Exterior Light Fixtures
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Collaborative Learning
      Alternative:VE56 - Delete Exterior Light Fixture Rough-In
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Collaborative Learning
      Alternative:VE63b - Remove New Concrete East of Building
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Collaborative Learning
      Alternative:VE64b - Remove Benches
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      5
      5.00
      100.00
      Goal:Collaborative Learning
      Alternative:VE15 - Delete Rolling Partition Support Steel
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Collaborative Learning
      Alternative:VE18b - Utilize comparable system to Kawneer 1600 Wall System 1
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Collaborative Learning
      Alternative:VE21b - Keep existing brick cavity wall on North & South Elevations
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Collaborative Learning
      Alternative:Brick Stain on N/S Elevations
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Collaborative Learning
      79.00%
      -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
      [Note: Priority #4 per Programmatic Objectives Document.]
    • Designer
      [X]
      Goal: Lighting/Daylighting
      Unit
      -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
      Criterion
      Applies to both shared daylighting from exterior, and quality of interior light generally. [Note: Priority #1 per Programmatic Objectives Document.]
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Lighting/Daylighting
      Alternative:A1a - Carpet in Offices
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Lighting/Daylighting
      Alternative:A1b - Carpet in Open Conference
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Lighting/Daylighting
      Alternative:A1c - Carpet in Collaboration Space
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Lighting/Daylighting
      Alternative:A2 - Tile Floors
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Lighting/Daylighting
      Alternative:A3a - Acoustical Ceiling in Flex Space
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Lighting/Daylighting
      Alternative:A3b - Acoustical Ceiling in PhD Space
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Lighting/Daylighting
      Alternative:A4 - Energy Dashboard
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Lighting/Daylighting
      Alternative:A5 - Visual Display Boards
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Lighting/Daylighting
      Alternative:A6 - Sidewalk & Courtyard Replacement
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Lighting/Daylighting
      Alternative:VE24 - Carbon Steel Picket Rail in lieu of Glass Rail @ Stair
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      5
      5.00
      100.00
      Goal:Lighting/Daylighting
      Alternative:VE26 - Delete Drywall Soffits/Projections @ Offices
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      5
      5.00
      100.00
      Goal:Lighting/Daylighting
      Alternative:VE27 - Delete Drywall Soffits/Projections @ Corridors & Conf Rms
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Lighting/Daylighting
      Alternative:VE28 - Install 2'x2' Acoustical Ceilings in lieu of Tectum Panels
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      5
      5.00
      100.00
      Goal:Lighting/Daylighting
      Alternative:VE32 - Delete Skylights in their Entirety
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Lighting/Daylighting
      Alternative:VE55 - Delete Exterior Light Fixtures
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Lighting/Daylighting
      Alternative:VE56 - Delete Exterior Light Fixture Rough-In
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Lighting/Daylighting
      Alternative:VE63b - Remove New Concrete East of Building
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Lighting/Daylighting
      Alternative:VE64b - Remove Benches
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Lighting/Daylighting
      Alternative:VE15 - Delete Rolling Partition Support Steel
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Lighting/Daylighting
      Alternative:VE18b - Utilize comparable system to Kawneer 1600 Wall System 1
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Lighting/Daylighting
      Alternative:VE21b - Keep existing brick cavity wall on North & South Elevations
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Attribute
      Advantage
      0.00
      Goal:Lighting/Daylighting
      Alternative:Brick Stain on N/S Elevations
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Lighting/Daylighting
      91.00%
      -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
      Applies to both shared daylighting from exterior, and quality of interior light generally. [Note: Priority #1 per Programmatic Objectives Document.]
    • Designer
      [X]
      Goal: Acoustics
      Unit
      -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
      Criterion
      Ambient noise absorption, speech intelligibility, and privacy.
      3
      3.00
      60.00
      Goal:Acoustics
      Alternative:A1a - Carpet in Offices
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      3
      3.00
      60.00
      Goal:Acoustics
      Alternative:A1b - Carpet in Open Conference
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      3
      3.00
      60.00
      Goal:Acoustics
      Alternative:A1c - Carpet in Collaboration Space
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Acoustics
      Alternative:A2 - Tile Floors
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      5
      5.00
      100.00
      Goal:Acoustics
      Alternative:A3a - Acoustical Ceiling in Flex Space
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      5
      5.00
      100.00
      Goal:Acoustics
      Alternative:A3b - Acoustical Ceiling in PhD Space
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Acoustics
      Alternative:A4 - Energy Dashboard
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Acoustics
      Alternative:A5 - Visual Display Boards
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Acoustics
      Alternative:A6 - Sidewalk & Courtyard Replacement
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Acoustics
      Alternative:VE24 - Carbon Steel Picket Rail in lieu of Glass Rail @ Stair
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Acoustics
      Alternative:VE26 - Delete Drywall Soffits/Projections @ Offices
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Acoustics
      Alternative:VE27 - Delete Drywall Soffits/Projections @ Corridors & Conf Rms
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      3
      3.00
      60.00
      Goal:Acoustics
      Alternative:VE28 - Install 2'x2' Acoustical Ceilings in lieu of Tectum Panels
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Acoustics
      Alternative:VE32 - Delete Skylights in their Entirety
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Acoustics
      Alternative:VE55 - Delete Exterior Light Fixtures
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Acoustics
      Alternative:VE56 - Delete Exterior Light Fixture Rough-In
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Acoustics
      Alternative:VE63b - Remove New Concrete East of Building
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Acoustics
      Alternative:VE64b - Remove Benches
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      5
      5.00
      100.00
      Goal:Acoustics
      Alternative:VE15 - Delete Rolling Partition Support Steel
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Acoustics
      Alternative:VE18b - Utilize comparable system to Kawneer 1600 Wall System 1
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Acoustics
      Alternative:VE21b - Keep existing brick cavity wall on North & South Elevations
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Attribute
      Advantage
      0.00
      Goal:Acoustics
      Alternative:Brick Stain on N/S Elevations
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Acoustics
      96.00%
      -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
      Ambient noise absorption, speech intelligibility, and privacy.
    • Designer
      [X]
      Goal: Thermal Comfort
      Unit
      -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
      Criterion
      2
      2.00
      40.00
      Goal:Thermal Comfort
      Alternative:A1a - Carpet in Offices
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      2
      2.00
      40.00
      Goal:Thermal Comfort
      Alternative:A1b - Carpet in Open Conference
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      2
      2.00
      40.00
      Goal:Thermal Comfort
      Alternative:A1c - Carpet in Collaboration Space
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Thermal Comfort
      Alternative:A2 - Tile Floors
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Thermal Comfort
      Alternative:A3a - Acoustical Ceiling in Flex Space
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Thermal Comfort
      Alternative:A3b - Acoustical Ceiling in PhD Space
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Thermal Comfort
      Alternative:A4 - Energy Dashboard
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Thermal Comfort
      Alternative:A5 - Visual Display Boards
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Thermal Comfort
      Alternative:A6 - Sidewalk & Courtyard Replacement
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Thermal Comfort
      Alternative:VE24 - Carbon Steel Picket Rail in lieu of Glass Rail @ Stair
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Thermal Comfort
      Alternative:VE26 - Delete Drywall Soffits/Projections @ Offices
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Thermal Comfort
      Alternative:VE27 - Delete Drywall Soffits/Projections @ Corridors & Conf Rms
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Thermal Comfort
      Alternative:VE28 - Install 2'x2' Acoustical Ceilings in lieu of Tectum Panels
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Thermal Comfort
      Alternative:VE32 - Delete Skylights in their Entirety
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Thermal Comfort
      Alternative:VE55 - Delete Exterior Light Fixtures
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Thermal Comfort
      Alternative:VE56 - Delete Exterior Light Fixture Rough-In
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Thermal Comfort
      Alternative:VE63b - Remove New Concrete East of Building
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Thermal Comfort
      Alternative:VE64b - Remove Benches
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Thermal Comfort
      Alternative:VE15 - Delete Rolling Partition Support Steel
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Thermal Comfort
      Alternative:VE18b - Utilize comparable system to Kawneer 1600 Wall System 1
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Thermal Comfort
      Alternative:VE21b - Keep existing brick cavity wall on North & South Elevations
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Attribute
      Advantage
      0.00
      Goal:Thermal Comfort
      Alternative:Brick Stain on N/S Elevations
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Thermal Comfort
      74.00%
      -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
    • Designer
      [X]
      Goal: Exterior Architecture
      Unit
      -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
      Criterion
      General aspects of exterior appearance and function. [Note: Priority #2 per Programmatic Objectives Document.]
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Exterior Architecture
      Alternative:A1a - Carpet in Offices
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Exterior Architecture
      Alternative:A1b - Carpet in Open Conference
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Exterior Architecture
      Alternative:A1c - Carpet in Collaboration Space
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Exterior Architecture
      Alternative:A2 - Tile Floors
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Exterior Architecture
      Alternative:A3a - Acoustical Ceiling in Flex Space
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Exterior Architecture
      Alternative:A3b - Acoustical Ceiling in PhD Space
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Exterior Architecture
      Alternative:A4 - Energy Dashboard
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Exterior Architecture
      Alternative:A5 - Visual Display Boards
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      4
      4.00
      0.00
      Goal:Exterior Architecture
      Alternative:A6 - Sidewalk & Courtyard Replacement
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Exterior Architecture
      Alternative:VE24 - Carbon Steel Picket Rail in lieu of Glass Rail @ Stair
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Exterior Architecture
      Alternative:VE26 - Delete Drywall Soffits/Projections @ Offices
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Exterior Architecture
      Alternative:VE27 - Delete Drywall Soffits/Projections @ Corridors & Conf Rms
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Exterior Architecture
      Alternative:VE28 - Install 2'x2' Acoustical Ceilings in lieu of Tectum Panels
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Exterior Architecture
      Alternative:VE32 - Delete Skylights in their Entirety
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      2
      2.00
      0.00
      Goal:Exterior Architecture
      Alternative:VE55 - Delete Exterior Light Fixtures
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      2
      2.00
      0.00
      Goal:Exterior Architecture
      Alternative:VE56 - Delete Exterior Light Fixture Rough-In
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      2
      2.00
      0.00
      Goal:Exterior Architecture
      Alternative:VE63b - Remove New Concrete East of Building
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      2
      2.00
      0.00
      Goal:Exterior Architecture
      Alternative:VE64b - Remove Benches
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Exterior Architecture
      Alternative:VE15 - Delete Rolling Partition Support Steel
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      5
      5.00
      0.00
      Goal:Exterior Architecture
      Alternative:VE18b - Utilize comparable system to Kawneer 1600 Wall System 1
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      5
      5.00
      0.00
      Goal:Exterior Architecture
      Alternative:VE21b - Keep existing brick cavity wall on North & South Elevations
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Attribute
      Advantage
      0.00
      Goal:Exterior Architecture
      Alternative:Brick Stain on N/S Elevations
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Exterior Architecture
      65.00%
      -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
      General aspects of exterior appearance and function. [Note: Priority #2 per Programmatic Objectives Document.]
    • Designer
      [X]
      Goal: Interior Architecture
      Unit
      -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
      Criterion
      General aspects of interior appearance and function. [Note: Priority #6 per Programmatic Objectives Document.]
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Interior Architecture
      Alternative:A1a - Carpet in Offices
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Interior Architecture
      Alternative:A1b - Carpet in Open Conference
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Interior Architecture
      Alternative:A1c - Carpet in Collaboration Space
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Interior Architecture
      Alternative:A2 - Tile Floors
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      3
      3.00
      60.00
      Goal:Interior Architecture
      Alternative:A3a - Acoustical Ceiling in Flex Space
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      3
      3.00
      60.00
      Goal:Interior Architecture
      Alternative:A3b - Acoustical Ceiling in PhD Space
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Interior Architecture
      Alternative:A4 - Energy Dashboard
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Interior Architecture
      Alternative:A5 - Visual Display Boards
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Interior Architecture
      Alternative:A6 - Sidewalk & Courtyard Replacement
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      5
      5.00
      100.00
      Goal:Interior Architecture
      Alternative:VE24 - Carbon Steel Picket Rail in lieu of Glass Rail @ Stair
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      5
      5.00
      100.00
      Goal:Interior Architecture
      Alternative:VE26 - Delete Drywall Soffits/Projections @ Offices
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      5
      5.00
      100.00
      Goal:Interior Architecture
      Alternative:VE27 - Delete Drywall Soffits/Projections @ Corridors & Conf Rms
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      5
      5.00
      100.00
      Goal:Interior Architecture
      Alternative:VE28 - Install 2'x2' Acoustical Ceilings in lieu of Tectum Panels
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      3
      3.00
      60.00
      Goal:Interior Architecture
      Alternative:VE32 - Delete Skylights in their Entirety
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Interior Architecture
      Alternative:VE55 - Delete Exterior Light Fixtures
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Interior Architecture
      Alternative:VE56 - Delete Exterior Light Fixture Rough-In
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Interior Architecture
      Alternative:VE63b - Remove New Concrete East of Building
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Interior Architecture
      Alternative:VE64b - Remove Benches
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Interior Architecture
      Alternative:VE15 - Delete Rolling Partition Support Steel
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Interior Architecture
      Alternative:VE18b - Utilize comparable system to Kawneer 1600 Wall System 1
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Interior Architecture
      Alternative:VE21b - Keep existing brick cavity wall on North & South Elevations
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Attribute
      Advantage
      0.00
      Goal:Interior Architecture
      Alternative:Brick Stain on N/S Elevations
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Interior Architecture
      64.00%
      -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
      General aspects of interior appearance and function. [Note: Priority #6 per Programmatic Objectives Document.]
    • Designer
      [X]
      Goal: Energy Efficiency
      Unit
      -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
      Criterion
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Energy Efficiency
      Alternative:A1a - Carpet in Offices
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Energy Efficiency
      Alternative:A1b - Carpet in Open Conference
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Energy Efficiency
      Alternative:A1c - Carpet in Collaboration Space
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Energy Efficiency
      Alternative:A2 - Tile Floors
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Energy Efficiency
      Alternative:A3a - Acoustical Ceiling in Flex Space
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Energy Efficiency
      Alternative:A3b - Acoustical Ceiling in PhD Space
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      5
      5.00
      100.00
      Goal:Energy Efficiency
      Alternative:A4 - Energy Dashboard
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Energy Efficiency
      Alternative:A5 - Visual Display Boards
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Energy Efficiency
      Alternative:A6 - Sidewalk & Courtyard Replacement
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Energy Efficiency
      Alternative:VE24 - Carbon Steel Picket Rail in lieu of Glass Rail @ Stair
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Energy Efficiency
      Alternative:VE26 - Delete Drywall Soffits/Projections @ Offices
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Energy Efficiency
      Alternative:VE27 - Delete Drywall Soffits/Projections @ Corridors & Conf Rms
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Energy Efficiency
      Alternative:VE28 - Install 2'x2' Acoustical Ceilings in lieu of Tectum Panels
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      5
      5.00
      100.00
      Goal:Energy Efficiency
      Alternative:VE32 - Delete Skylights in their Entirety
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Energy Efficiency
      Alternative:VE55 - Delete Exterior Light Fixtures
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Energy Efficiency
      Alternative:VE56 - Delete Exterior Light Fixture Rough-In
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Energy Efficiency
      Alternative:VE63b - Remove New Concrete East of Building
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Energy Efficiency
      Alternative:VE64b - Remove Benches
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Energy Efficiency
      Alternative:VE15 - Delete Rolling Partition Support Steel
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Energy Efficiency
      Alternative:VE18b - Utilize comparable system to Kawneer 1600 Wall System 1
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      0.00
      Goal:Energy Efficiency
      Alternative:VE21b - Keep existing brick cavity wall on North & South Elevations
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Attribute
      Advantage
      0.00
      Goal:Energy Efficiency
      Alternative:Brick Stain on N/S Elevations
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Energy Efficiency
      66.00%
      -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
  • Constraints

Teams

  • Deciders
    • Name: John Haymaker
      Email: johnrhaymaker@gmail.com
      John Haymaker
    • CPSM
      • Name: Howard Wertheimer
        Email: howard.wertheimer@spaceplan.gatech.edu
        Howard Wertheimer
      • Name: Daniel Nemec
        Email: dnemec@spaceplan.gatech.edu
        Daniel Nemec
    • Building Construction
      • Name: Daniel Castro
        Email: daniel.castro@coa.gatech.edu
        Daniel Castro
    • Design and Construction
      • Name: Scott Jones
        Email: scott.jones@facilities.gatech.edu
        Scott Jones
      • Name: Gary Jelin
        Email: gary.jelin@facilities.gatech.edu
        Gary Jelin
      • Name: Jennifer Disotell
        Email: jennifer.disotell@facilities.gatech.edu
        Jennifer Disotell
    • BLDGS
      • Evergreen
      • Stakeholders
        • CPSM
          • Name: Howard Wertheimer
            Email: howard.wertheimer@spaceplan.gatech.edu
            Howard Wertheimer
        • D&C
          • Name: Gary Jelin
            Email: gary.jelin@facilities.gatech.edu
            Gary Jelin
        • BC
          • Name: Daniel Castro
            Email: daniel.castro@coa.gatech.edu
            Daniel Castro
        • BLDGS
          • Name: David Yocum
            Email: dy@bldgs.org
            David Yocum
        • Evergreen
          • Name: Hunter Letts
            Email: hletts@evergreencorp.com
            Hunter Letts
      • Gatekeepers
        • Name: John Haymaker
          Email: johnrhaymaker@gmail.com
          John Haymaker
      • Designers
        • Name: John Haymaker
          Email: johnrhaymaker@gmail.com
          John Haymaker
        • Design & Construction
          • Name: Jennifer Disotell
            Email: jennifer.disotell@facilities.gatech.edu
            Jennifer Disotell
        • BLDGS
          • Name: David Yocum
            Email: dy@bldgs.org
            David Yocum
        • Evergreen
          • Name: Hunter Letts
            Email: hletts@evergreencorp.com
            Hunter Letts
      • Observers

      Goals

      • Goals
        • [X]
          Folder:Goals
          Goal: Collaborative Learning
          Unit
          -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
          Criterion
          [Note: Priority #4 per Programmatic Objectives Document.]
          Collaborative Learning
          -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
          [Note: Priority #4 per Programmatic Objectives Document.]
        • [X]
          Folder:Goals
          Goal: Lighting/Daylighting
          Unit
          -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
          Criterion
          Applies to both shared daylighting from exterior, and quality of interior light generally. [Note: Priority #1 per Programmatic Objectives Document.]
          Lighting/Daylighting
          -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
          Applies to both shared daylighting from exterior, and quality of interior light generally. [Note: Priority #1 per Programmatic Objectives Document.]
        • [X]
          Folder:Goals
          Goal: Acoustics
          Unit
          -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
          Criterion
          Ambient noise absorption, speech intelligibility, and privacy.
          Acoustics
          -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
          Ambient noise absorption, speech intelligibility, and privacy.
        • [X]
          Folder:Goals
          Goal: Thermal Comfort
          Unit
          -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)
          Criterion
          Thermal Comfort
          -5 (bad impact) to 0 (neutral) to 5 (good impact)