Decision Summary

Alternatives:
Varied Workspaces
Winner
More Info
[X]
Alternative: Varied Workspaces
Additional information
Building layout that includes of study/meeting spaces for individuals to choose from based on their needs/wants
Uniform Workspaces More Info
[X]
Alternative: Uniform Workspaces
Additional information
Many of the same types of space to minimize competition between individuals
Unique Space More Info
[X]
Alternative: Unique Space
Additional information
Include movable partitions in the design so the type of space can be modified per the users individual requirements
Total Value:
230.00
230.00
155.00
110.00
Values:
0.0
Increased Collaboration More Info
10 interactions/hour
50.00
Increased Building Use More Info
5 visits/week
40.00
High Functionality More Info
3 maintenance requests
20.00
Increased Comfort More Info
10 time
70.00
First Cost More Info
24753.48 $
25.00
Lifecycle Cost More Info
800 $
25.00
Increased Collaboration More Info
10 interactions/hour
50.00
High Functionality More Info
4 maintenance requests
20.00
First Cost More Info
10943.40 $
50.00
Lifecycle Cost More Info
550 $
35.00
Increased Building Use More Info
2 visits/week
40.00
Enable Private Conversations More Info
0 interruptions
50.00
Increased Comfort More Info
5 time
20.00
Goal: Increased Collaboration
Alternative: Varied Workspaces
Impact Value
0.50 50.00
Goal: Increased Building Use
Alternative: Varied Workspaces
Impact Value
0.40 40.00
Goal: High Functionality
Alternative: Varied Workspaces
Impact Value
0.20 20.00
Goal: Increased Comfort
Alternative: Varied Workspaces
Impact Value
0.70 70.00
Goal: First Cost
Alternative: Varied Workspaces
Impact Value
0.25 25.00
Goal: Lifecycle Cost
Alternative: Varied Workspaces
Impact Value
0.25 25.00
Goal: Increased Collaboration
Alternative: Uniform Workspaces
Impact Value
0.50 50.00
Goal: High Functionality
Alternative: Uniform Workspaces
Impact Value
0.20 20.00
Goal: First Cost
Alternative: Uniform Workspaces
Impact Value
0.50 50.00
Goal: Lifecycle Cost
Alternative: Uniform Workspaces
Impact Value
0.35 35.00
Goal: Increased Building Use
Alternative: Unique Space
Impact Value
0.40 40.00
Goal: Enable Private Conversations
Alternative: Unique Space
Impact Value
0.50 50.00
Goal: Increased Comfort
Alternative: Unique Space
Impact Value
0.20 20.00

Value by Goal

  • Alternatives
    • [X]
      Alternative: Varied Workspaces
      Additional information
      Building layout that includes of study/meeting spaces for individuals to choose from based on their needs/wants
      Varied Workspaces
    • [X]
      Alternative: Uniform Workspaces
      Additional information
      Many of the same types of space to minimize competition between individuals
      Uniform Workspaces
    • [X]
      Alternative: Unique Space
      Additional information
      Include movable partitions in the design so the type of space can be modified per the users individual requirements
      Unique Space
  • Legend
    Objectives Select All Select All Leaf Objectives Unselect All
    • [X]
      Goal: Increased Collaboration
      Unit
      interactions/hour
      Criterion
      Increase the possibility for interaction and conversation between individuals
      Increased Collaboration
    • [X]
      Goal: Increased Building Use
      Unit
      visits/week
      Criterion
      Increase students use of the facility for studying/homework instead of using other campus facilities
      Increased Building Use
    • [X]
      Goal: Increase Productivity
      Unit
      Visits/week
      Criterion
      Increase the productivity of those using the space based on the assumption that people tend to work where they feel they are most productive
      Increase Productivity
    • [X]
      Goal: High Functionality
      Unit
      maintenance requests
      Criterion
      Minimize number of malfunctions/failures in the space that could negatively impact the health, safety or comfort of the users
      High Functionality
    • [X]
      Goal: Enable Private Conversations
      Unit
      interruptions
      Criterion
      Provide quiet space for those who desire or need it to carry out private conversations , etc.
      Enable Private Conversations
    • [X]
      Goal: Increased Comfort
      Unit
      time
      Criterion
      Increase the physical comfort of those using the building based on the assumption people will spend more time where they are comfortable
      Increased Comfort
    • [X]
      Goal: Economic Analysis
      Criterion
      Economic Analysis of each layout option
      Economic Analysis
      • [X]
        Goal: First Cost
        Unit
        $
        Criterion
        Minimize first cost associated with the workspace
        First Cost
      • [X]
        Goal: Lifecycle Cost
        Unit
        $
        Criterion
        Minimize Cost of Space over its useable lifetime
        Lifecycle Cost

Goal Weights

Stakeholder Name:
Goal Weight:
    Goals are not weighted in this decision.

Stakeholder Weights

    Stakeholders are not weighted in this decision.

Impact

  • Varied Workspaces
    Varied Workspaces
    [X]
    Alternative: Varied Workspaces
    Additional information
    Building layout that includes of study/meeting spaces for individuals to choose from based on their needs/wants
  • Uniform Workspaces
    Uniform Workspaces
    [X]
    Alternative: Uniform Workspaces
    Additional information
    Many of the same types of space to minimize competition between individuals
  • Unique Space
    Unique Space
    [X]
    Alternative: Unique Space
    Additional information
    Include movable partitions in the design so the type of space can be modified per the users individual requirements
  • Goals
    • Designer
      [X]
      Goal: Increased Collaboration
      Unit
      interactions/hour
      Criterion
      Increase the possibility for interaction and conversation between individuals
      10
      10.00
      50.00
      Goal:Increased Collaboration
      Alternative:Varied Workspaces
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      10
      10.00
      50.00
      Goal:Increased Collaboration
      Alternative:Uniform Workspaces
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      0.00
      Impact --
      Goal:Increased Collaboration
      Alternative:Unique Space
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Increased Collaboration
      interactions/hour
      Increase the possibility for interaction and conversation between individuals
    • Designer
      [X]
      Goal: Increased Building Use
      Unit
      visits/week
      Criterion
      Increase students use of the facility for studying/homework instead of using other campus facilities
      5
      4.00
      40.00
      Goal:Increased Building Use
      Alternative:Varied Workspaces
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      1
      0.00
      Impact --
      Goal:Increased Building Use
      Alternative:Uniform Workspaces
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      2
      1.00
      40.00
      Goal:Increased Building Use
      Alternative:Unique Space
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Increased Building Use
      visits/week
      Increase students use of the facility for studying/homework instead of using other campus facilities
    • Designer
      [X]
      Goal: Increase Productivity
      Unit
      Visits/week
      Criterion
      Increase the productivity of those using the space based on the assumption that people tend to work where they feel they are most productive
      Attribute
      Advantage
      Impact --
      Goal:Increase Productivity
      Alternative:Varied Workspaces
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Attribute
      Advantage
      Impact --
      Goal:Increase Productivity
      Alternative:Uniform Workspaces
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Attribute
      Advantage
      Impact --
      Goal:Increase Productivity
      Alternative:Unique Space
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Increase Productivity
      Visits/week
      Increase the productivity of those using the space based on the assumption that people tend to work where they feel they are most productive
    • Designer
      [X]
      Goal: High Functionality
      Unit
      maintenance requests
      Criterion
      Minimize number of malfunctions/failures in the space that could negatively impact the health, safety or comfort of the users
      3
      -2.00
      20.00
      Goal:High Functionality
      Alternative:Varied Workspaces
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      4
      -1.00
      20.00
      Goal:High Functionality
      Alternative:Uniform Workspaces
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      5
      0.00
      Impact --
      Goal:High Functionality
      Alternative:Unique Space
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      High Functionality
      maintenance requests
      Minimize number of malfunctions/failures in the space that could negatively impact the health, safety or comfort of the users
    • Designer
      [X]
      Goal: Enable Private Conversations
      Unit
      interruptions
      Criterion
      Provide quiet space for those who desire or need it to carry out private conversations , etc.
      10
      0.00
      Impact --
      Goal:Enable Private Conversations
      Alternative:Varied Workspaces
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      10
      0.00
      Impact --
      Goal:Enable Private Conversations
      Alternative:Uniform Workspaces
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      0
      -10.00
      50.00
      Goal:Enable Private Conversations
      Alternative:Unique Space
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Enable Private Conversations
      interruptions
      Provide quiet space for those who desire or need it to carry out private conversations , etc.
    • Designer
      [X]
      Goal: Increased Comfort
      Unit
      time
      Criterion
      Increase the physical comfort of those using the building based on the assumption people will spend more time where they are comfortable
      10
      7.00
      70.00
      Goal:Increased Comfort
      Alternative:Varied Workspaces
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      3
      0.00
      Impact --
      Goal:Increased Comfort
      Alternative:Uniform Workspaces
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      5
      2.00
      20.00
      Goal:Increased Comfort
      Alternative:Unique Space
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Increased Comfort
      time
      Increase the physical comfort of those using the building based on the assumption people will spend more time where they are comfortable
    • [X]
      Goal: Economic Analysis
      Criterion
      Economic Analysis of each layout option
      Economic Analysis
      Economic Analysis of each layout option
      • Designer
        [X]
        Goal: First Cost
        Unit
        $
        Criterion
        Minimize first cost associated with the workspace
        24753.48
        -32579.92
        25.00
        Goal:First Cost
        Alternative:Varied Workspaces
        Additional information:


        URL: http://
        10943.40
        -46390.00
        50.00
        Goal:First Cost
        Alternative:Uniform Workspaces
        Additional information:


        URL: http://
        57333.4
        0.00
        Impact --
        Goal:First Cost
        Alternative:Unique Space
        Additional information:


        URL: http://
        First Cost
        $
        Minimize first cost associated with the workspace
      • Designer
        [X]
        Goal: Lifecycle Cost
        Unit
        $
        Criterion
        Minimize Cost of Space over its useable lifetime
        800
        -500.00
        25.00
        Goal:Lifecycle Cost
        Alternative:Varied Workspaces
        Additional information:


        URL: http://
        550
        -750.00
        35.00
        Goal:Lifecycle Cost
        Alternative:Uniform Workspaces
        Additional information:


        URL: http://
        1300
        0.00
        Impact --
        Goal:Lifecycle Cost
        Alternative:Unique Space
        Additional information:


        URL: http://
        Lifecycle Cost
        $
        Minimize Cost of Space over its useable lifetime
  • Constraints

Teams

  • Deciders
    • Name: Erica Hanselman
      Email: Ehanselman@gatech.edu
      Erica Hanselman
    • Name: John Haymaker
      Email: johnrhaymaker@gmail.com
      John Haymaker
    • Name: David Hannon
      Email: gtg012a@mail.gatech.edu
      David Hannon
  • Stakeholders
    • Name: Erica Hanselman
      Email: Ehanselman@gatech.edu
      Erica Hanselman
  • Gatekeepers
    • Name: Erica Hanselman
      Email: Ehanselman@gatech.edu
      Erica Hanselman
  • Designers
    • Name: Erica Hanselman
      Email: Ehanselman@gatech.edu
      Erica Hanselman
  • Observers

Goals

  • Goals
    • [X]
      Folder:Goals
      Goal: Increased Collaboration
      Unit
      interactions/hour
      Criterion
      Increase the possibility for interaction and conversation between individuals
      Increased Collaboration
      interactions/hour
      Increase the possibility for interaction and conversation between individuals
    • [X]
      Folder:Goals
      Goal: Increased Building Use
      Unit
      visits/week
      Criterion
      Increase students use of the facility for studying/homework instead of using other campus facilities
      Increased Building Use
      visits/week
      Increase students use of the facility for studying/homework instead of using other campus facilities
    • [X]
      Folder:Goals
      Goal: Increase Productivity
      Unit
      Visits/week
      Criterion
      Increase the productivity of those using the space based on the assumption that people tend to work where they feel they are most productive
      Increase Productivity
      Visits/week
      Increase the productivity of those using the space based on the assumption that people tend to work where they feel they are most productive
    • [X]
      Folder:Goals
      Goal: High Functionality
      Unit
      maintenance requests
      Criterion
      Minimize number of malfunctions/failures in the space that could negatively impact the health, safety or comfort of the users
      High Functionality
      maintenance requests
      Minimize number of malfunctions/failures in the space that could negatively impact the health, safety or comfort of the users
    • [X]
      Folder:Goals
      Goal: Enable Private Conversations
      Unit
      interruptions
      Criterion
      Provide quiet space for those who desire or need it to carry out private conversations , etc.
      Enable Private Conversations
      interruptions
      Provide quiet space for those who desire or need it to carry out private conversations , etc.
    • [X]
      Folder:Goals
      Goal: Increased Comfort
      Unit
      time
      Criterion
      Increase the physical comfort of those using the building based on the assumption people will spend more time where they are comfortable
      Increased Comfort
      time
      Increase the physical comfort of those using the building based on the assumption people will spend more time where they are comfortable
    • [X]
      Folder:Goals
      Goal: Environmental Goals
      Criterion
      Project Objectives related to the environment
      Environmental Goals
      Project Objectives related to the environment
      • [X]
        Goal: Bicycle Use
        Unit
        # of users using bicycles at building
        Criterion
        Maximize the number of building users who utilize bicycles to arrive at building instead of campus transit or cars
        Bicycle Use
        # of users using bicycles at building
        Maximize the number of building users who utilize bicycles to arrive at building instead of campus transit or cars
      • [X]
        Goal: Heat Island Effect
        Unit
        % of non-heat island effect creating surfaces to heat island creating surfaces
        Criterion
        Maximize the percentage of materials that do not create a heat island effect
        Heat Island Effect
        % of non-heat island effect creating surfaces to heat island creating surfaces
        Maximize the percentage of materials that do not create a heat island effect
      • [X]
        Goal: Light Pollution
        Unit
        % of light escape
        Criterion
        Minimize amount of light that escapes from the building interior and amount of exterior light while maintaining a safe environment
        Light Pollution
        % of light escape
        Minimize amount of light that escapes from the building interior and amount of exterior light while maintaining a safe environment
      • [X]
        Goal: Water Useage
        Unit
        % reduction in water use
        Criterion
        Minimize the amount of water (maximize the reduction percentage) used within the building by improving efficiency of fixtures
        Water Useage
        % reduction in water use
        Minimize the amount of water (maximize the reduction percentage) used within the building by improving efficiency of fixtures
      • [X]
        Goal: Lighting
        Unit
        sf lit without a user
        Criterion
        Minimize amount of unnecessary lighting, ie. no lighting in areas not in use
        Lighting
        sf lit without a user
        Minimize amount of unnecessary lighting, ie. no lighting in areas not in use
      • [X]
        Goal: Heating/Cooling
        Unit
        sf
        Criterion
        minimize temperature regulation in areas not in use
        Heating/Cooling
        sf
        minimize temperature regulation in areas not in use
    • [X]
      Folder:Goals
      Goal: Economic Analysis
      Criterion
      Economic Analysis of each layout option
      Economic Analysis
      Economic Analysis of each layout option
      • [X]
        Folder:Economic Analysis
        Goal: First Cost
        Unit
        $
        Criterion
        Minimize first cost associated with the workspace
        First Cost
        $
        Minimize first cost associated with the workspace
      • [X]
        Folder:Economic Analysis
        Goal: Lifecycle Cost
        Unit
        $
        Criterion
        Minimize Cost of Space over its useable lifetime
        Lifecycle Cost
        $
        Minimize Cost of Space over its useable lifetime

Constraints

  • Constraints

Alternatives

  • Alternatives
    • [X]
      Folder:Alternatives
      Alternative: Varied Workspaces
      Additional information
      Building layout that includes of study/meeting spaces for individuals to choose from based on their needs/wants
      Varied Workspaces
      Building layout that includes of study/meeting spaces for individuals to choose from based on their needs/wants
    • [X]
      Folder:Alternatives
      Alternative: Uniform Workspaces
      Additional information
      Many of the same types of space to minimize competition between individuals
      Uniform Workspaces
      Many of the same types of space to minimize competition between individuals
    • [X]
      Folder:Alternatives
      Alternative: Unique Space
      Additional information
      Include movable partitions in the design so the type of space can be modified per the users individual requirements
      Unique Space
      Include movable partitions in the design so the type of space can be modified per the users individual requirements