• Third Floor Addition Concept
    Third Floor Addition Concept
    [X]
    Alternative: Third Floor Addition Concept
    Additional information
    This concept is desired by BC Faculty, including three floors. First and second floors are reconfigured and refreshed spaces and the third floor is new constructed.
    Construction cost is: $2,600,000
  • Third Floor Addition Concept + Flexible Spaces
    Third Floor Addition Concept + Flexible Spaces
    [X]
    Alternative: Third Floor Addition Concept + Flexible Spaces
    Additional information
    This concept includes a three floor building which the 1st and 2nd floor are reconfigured and refreshed spaces and the third one is new constructed.
    The main characteristic of this concept is its flexibility in 2nd and 3rd floor which enables us to reconfigure it by new function and access.
    Construction cost is: $2,600,000
  • Frontal Addition Concept
    Frontal Addition Concept
    [X]
    Alternative: Frontal Addition Concept
    Additional information
    This concept includes two floors which both of them are reconfigured and refreshed spaces.
    The main characteristic of this concept is the frontal addition to the building.
    Construction cost is: $2,600,000
  • Frontal Addition Concept + Third Floor Addition
    Frontal Addition Concept + Third Floor Addition
    [X]
    Alternative: Frontal Addition Concept + Third Floor Addition
    Additional information
    This concept includes a three floor building which the 1st and 2nd floor are reconfigured and refreshed spaces and the third one is new constructed.
    The main characteristics of this concept are its flexibility in 2nd and 3rd floor (which enables us to reconfigure it by new function and access) and the frontal addition.
    Construction cost is: $4,750,000
  • Goals
    • Designer
      [X]
      Goal: Aesthetics
      Unit
      Criterion
      Project needs to satisfy aesthetic aspects
      Flat Facede
      Advantage
      55.00
      Goal:Aesthetics
      Alternative:Third Floor Addition Concept
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Attribute
      Advantage
      80.00
      Goal:Aesthetics
      Alternative:Third Floor Addition Concept + Flexible Spaces
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Spacial Design
      Wider Facade
      80.00
      Goal:Aesthetics
      Alternative:Frontal Addition Concept
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Spacial Design
      Wider Facade
      85.00
      Goal:Aesthetics
      Alternative:Frontal Addition Concept + Third Floor Addition
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Aesthetics
      Project needs to satisfy aesthetic aspects
    • Designer
      [X]
      Goal: Accommodate Growth in Building Construction Program
      Unit
      Criterion
      One of the main project target is provide space for new programs
      Attribute
      Additional Space
      95.00
      Goal:Accommodate Growth in Building Construction Program
      Alternative:Third Floor Addition Concept
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Attribute
      Additional Space
      90.00
      Goal:Accommodate Growth in Building Construction Program
      Alternative:Third Floor Addition Concept + Flexible Spaces
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Attribute
      Advantage
      40.00
      Goal:Accommodate Growth in Building Construction Program
      Alternative:Frontal Addition Concept
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Attribute
      Additional Space
      90.00
      Goal:Accommodate Growth in Building Construction Program
      Alternative:Frontal Addition Concept + Third Floor Addition
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Accommodate Growth in Building Construction Program
      One of the main project target is provide space for new programs
    • Designer
      [X]
      Goal: Quality
      Unit
      Criterion
      .Continuous Improvement
      .Consistency
      .Teamwork
      .Routine Measure and Analysis
      .Training
      Attribute
      Advantage
      70.00
      Goal:Quality
      Alternative:Third Floor Addition Concept
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Fflexibility
      Team Working
      90.00
      Goal:Quality
      Alternative:Third Floor Addition Concept + Flexible Spaces
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Natural Lighting
      Advantage
      60.00
      Goal:Quality
      Alternative:Frontal Addition Concept
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Attribute
      Tem Working
      85.00
      Goal:Quality
      Alternative:Frontal Addition Concept + Third Floor Addition
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Quality
      .Continuous Improvement
      .Consistency
      .Teamwork
      .Routine Measure and Analysis
      .Training
  • Constraints
    • [X]
      Constraint: Budget
      Additional information
      There is limitation of 2.5 M. $ for the total project cost
      yes Info
      Constraint:Budget
      Alternative:Third Floor Addition Concept
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      yes Info
      Constraint:Budget
      Alternative:Third Floor Addition Concept + Flexible Spaces
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      yes Info
      Constraint:Budget
      Alternative:Frontal Addition Concept
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      no Info
      Constraint:Budget
      Alternative:Frontal Addition Concept + Third Floor Addition
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Budget
      There is limitation of 2.5 M. $ for the total project cost
    • [X]
      Constraint: Time Shedule
      Additional information
      Project should finished by Fall 2014
      yes Info
      Constraint:Time Shedule
      Alternative:Third Floor Addition Concept
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      yes Info
      Constraint:Time Shedule
      Alternative:Third Floor Addition Concept + Flexible Spaces
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      yes Info
      Constraint:Time Shedule
      Alternative:Frontal Addition Concept
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      yes Info
      Constraint:Time Shedule
      Alternative:Frontal Addition Concept + Third Floor Addition
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Time Shedule
      Project should finished by Fall 2014
    • [X]
      Constraint: Operation
      Additional information
      New building has different function in various levels
      yes Info
      Constraint:Operation
      Alternative:Third Floor Addition Concept
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      yes Info
      Constraint:Operation
      Alternative:Third Floor Addition Concept + Flexible Spaces
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      no Info
      Constraint:Operation
      Alternative:Frontal Addition Concept
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      yes Info
      Constraint:Operation
      Alternative:Frontal Addition Concept + Third Floor Addition
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Operation
      New building has different function in various levels
    • [X]
      Constraint: Land Use
      Additional information
      project should be built in determined area
      yes Info
      Constraint:Land Use
      Alternative:Third Floor Addition Concept
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      yes Info
      Constraint:Land Use
      Alternative:Third Floor Addition Concept + Flexible Spaces
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      no Info
      Constraint:Land Use
      Alternative:Frontal Addition Concept
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      no Info
      Constraint:Land Use
      Alternative:Frontal Addition Concept + Third Floor Addition
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Land Use
      project should be built in determined area
    • [X]
      Constraint: Codes & Regulations
      Additional information
      . Individual institution (Yellow Book at Ga. Tech)
      . Higher level institutional (State Construction Manual of Georgia; Corps of Engineers Standards for Construction)
      yes Info
      Constraint:Codes & Regulations
      Alternative:Third Floor Addition Concept
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      yes Info
      Constraint:Codes & Regulations
      Alternative:Third Floor Addition Concept + Flexible Spaces
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      yes Info
      Constraint:Codes & Regulations
      Alternative:Frontal Addition Concept
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      yes Info
      Constraint:Codes & Regulations
      Alternative:Frontal Addition Concept + Third Floor Addition
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Codes & Regulations
      . Individual institution (Yellow Book at Ga. Tech)
      . Higher level institutional (State Construction Manual of Georgia; Corps of Engineers Standards for Construction)
    • [X]
      Constraint: Sustainablity
      Additional information
      New building should meet LEED regulations
      yes Info
      Constraint:Sustainablity
      Alternative:Third Floor Addition Concept
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      yes Info
      Constraint:Sustainablity
      Alternative:Third Floor Addition Concept + Flexible Spaces
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      yes Info
      Constraint:Sustainablity
      Alternative:Frontal Addition Concept
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      yes Info
      Constraint:Sustainablity
      Alternative:Frontal Addition Concept + Third Floor Addition
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Sustainablity
      New building should meet LEED regulations

Alternatives:
Third Floor Addition Concept More Info
[X]
Alternative: Third Floor Addition Concept
Additional information
This concept is desired by BC Faculty, including three floors. First and second floors are reconfigured and refreshed spaces and the third floor is new constructed.
Construction cost is: $2,600,000
Third Floor Addition Concept + Flexible Spaces
Winner
More Info
[X]
Alternative: Third Floor Addition Concept + Flexible Spaces
Additional information
This concept includes a three floor building which the 1st and 2nd floor are reconfigured and refreshed spaces and the third one is new constructed.
The main characteristic of this concept is its flexibility in 2nd and 3rd floor which enables us to reconfigure it by new function and access.
Construction cost is: $2,600,000
Frontal Addition Concept More Info
[X]
Alternative: Frontal Addition Concept
Additional information
This concept includes two floors which both of them are reconfigured and refreshed spaces.
The main characteristic of this concept is the frontal addition to the building.
Construction cost is: $2,600,000
Frontal Addition Concept + Third Floor Addition More Info
[X]
Alternative: Frontal Addition Concept + Third Floor Addition
Additional information
This concept includes a three floor building which the 1st and 2nd floor are reconfigured and refreshed spaces and the third one is new constructed.
The main characteristics of this concept are its flexibility in 2nd and 3rd floor (which enables us to reconfigure it by new function and access) and the frontal addition.
Construction cost is: $4,750,000
Total Value:
260.00
220.00
260.00
180.00
260.00
Values:
0.0
Aesthetics More Info
Flat Facede
55.00
Accommodate Growth in Building Construction Program More Info
95.00
Quality More Info
70.00
Aesthetics More Info
80.00
Accommodate Growth in Building Construction Program More Info
90.00
Quality More Info
Fflexibility
90.00
Aesthetics More Info
Spacial Design
80.00
Accommodate Growth in Building Construction Program More Info
40.00
Quality More Info
Natural Lighting
60.00
Aesthetics More Info
Spacial Design
85.00
Accommodate Growth in Building Construction Program More Info
90.00
Quality More Info
85.00
Goal: Aesthetics
Alternative: Third Floor Addition Concept
Impact Value
0.55 55.00
Goal: Accommodate Growth in Building Construction Program
Alternative: Third Floor Addition Concept
Impact Value
0.95 95.00
Goal: Quality
Alternative: Third Floor Addition Concept
Impact Value
0.70 70.00
Goal: Aesthetics
Alternative: Third Floor Addition Concept + Flexible Spaces
Impact Value
0.80 80.00
Goal: Accommodate Growth in Building Construction Program
Alternative: Third Floor Addition Concept + Flexible Spaces
Impact Value
0.90 90.00
Goal: Quality
Alternative: Third Floor Addition Concept + Flexible Spaces
Impact Value
0.90 90.00
Goal: Aesthetics
Alternative: Frontal Addition Concept
Impact Value
0.80 80.00
Goal: Accommodate Growth in Building Construction Program
Alternative: Frontal Addition Concept
Impact Value
0.40 40.00
Goal: Quality
Alternative: Frontal Addition Concept
Impact Value
0.60 60.00
Goal: Aesthetics
Alternative: Frontal Addition Concept + Third Floor Addition
Impact Value
0.85 85.00
Goal: Accommodate Growth in Building Construction Program
Alternative: Frontal Addition Concept + Third Floor Addition
Impact Value
0.90 90.00
Goal: Quality
Alternative: Frontal Addition Concept + Third Floor Addition
Impact Value
0.85 85.00