• Reface the Facade of Existing Annex
    Reface the Facade of Existing Annex
    [X]
    Alternative: Reface the Facade of Existing Annex
    Additional information
    Keep the Existing Architecture Annex as a two story building. Renovate the interior and reface the facade.
  • Make the Construction Annex 3 Stories Tall with Varying Roof Heights
    Make the Construction Annex 3 Stories Tall with Varying Roof Heights
    [X]
    Alternative: Make the Construction Annex 3 Stories Tall with Varying Roof Heights
    Additional information
    This alternative involves making the architecture 3 stories tall. It has differing roof heights and is construction from a combination of brick, steel, and glass.
  • Make the Construction Annex 2 Stories Tall with Flat Roof
    Make the Construction Annex 2 Stories Tall with Flat Roof
    [X]
    Alternative: Make the Construction Annex 2 Stories Tall with Flat Roof
    Additional information
    This alternative involves making the architecture 3 stories tall. It has a single roof height and is construction from a combination of steel and glass only, no brick.
  • Goals
    • Designer
      [X]
      Goal: Character as a Public Object
      Unit
      % of people surveyed
      Criterion
      Buildings are first and foremost meant to serve in favor of people. Architecture is a public object meaning that there is no free choice as to whether the public may or may not observe it. The architect does not create their own public so the design has to be appealing to the public at large. In order to measure ?character as a public object? criterion survey the general public by showing them the proposed design alternatives and asking which design they prefer.
      0
      0.00
      -50.00
      Goal:Character as a Public Object
      Alternative:Reface the Facade of Existing Annex
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      87%
      Advantage
      87.00
      Goal:Character as a Public Object
      Alternative:Make the Construction Annex 3 Stories Tall with Varying Roof Heights
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      13%
      Advantage
      -13.00
      Goal:Character as a Public Object
      Alternative:Make the Construction Annex 2 Stories Tall with Flat Roof
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Character as a Public Object
      3.03%
      % of people surveyed
      Buildings are first and foremost meant to serve in favor of people. Architecture is a public object meaning that there is no free choice as to whether the public may or may not observe it. The architect does not create their own public so the design has to be appealing to the public at large. In order to measure ?character as a public object? criterion survey the general public by showing them the proposed design alternatives and asking which design they prefer.
    • Designer
      [X]
      Goal: Continuity with the Decorative Arts and Vernacular
      Unit
      # of shared attributes with surrounding buildings
      Criterion
      Even the aesthetic in a work of architecture is simply to ?look right? in its context. Vernacular architecture tends to evolve over time to reflect the environmental, cultural, technological, and historical context in which it exists. To quantify his criteria compare its size and physical attributes to the size and physical attributes (material, mass, proportion, line, etc) of other buildings nearby. If the structure compares favorable to these, then the building should be evaluated positively.
      1
      0.00
      -50.00
      Goal:Continuity with the Decorative Arts and Vernacular
      Alternative:Reface the Facade of Existing Annex
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      5
      4.00
      90.00
      Goal:Continuity with the Decorative Arts and Vernacular
      Alternative:Make the Construction Annex 3 Stories Tall with Varying Roof Heights
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      2
      1.00
      31.00
      Goal:Continuity with the Decorative Arts and Vernacular
      Alternative:Make the Construction Annex 2 Stories Tall with Flat Roof
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Continuity with the Decorative Arts and Vernacular
      2.43%
      # of shared attributes with surrounding buildings
      Even the aesthetic in a work of architecture is simply to ?look right? in its context. Vernacular architecture tends to evolve over time to reflect the environmental, cultural, technological, and historical context in which it exists. To quantify his criteria compare its size and physical attributes to the size and physical attributes (material, mass, proportion, line, etc) of other buildings nearby. If the structure compares favorable to these, then the building should be evaluated positively.
    • Designer
      [X]
      Goal: Aesthetic Harmony
      Unit
      score 1-3 for each design element (7 elements means 21 potential points). 1 being poor execution of design elements, 2 being fair execution of design elements, and 3 being good execution of design element.
      Criterion
      Seven principles encompass an interesting design: balance, rhythm, emphasis, proportion and scale, movement, contrast, unity.
      14
      0.00
      26.00
      Goal:Aesthetic Harmony
      Alternative:Reface the Facade of Existing Annex
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      20
      6.00
      84.00
      Goal:Aesthetic Harmony
      Alternative:Make the Construction Annex 3 Stories Tall with Varying Roof Heights
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      19
      5.00
      80.00
      Goal:Aesthetic Harmony
      Alternative:Make the Construction Annex 2 Stories Tall with Flat Roof
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Aesthetic Harmony
      2.13%
      score 1-3 for each design element (7 elements means 21 potential points). 1 being poor execution of design elements, 2 being fair execution of design elements, and 3 being good execution of design element.
      Seven principles encompass an interesting design: balance, rhythm, emphasis, proportion and scale, movement, contrast, unity.
    • Designer
      [X]
      Goal: Increase Collaboration
      Unit
      # of open spaces
      Criterion
      Open spaces encourage collaboration while closed spaces aren't as encouraging. Teamwork is a big part component of the re-design of the BC Annex.
      0
      0.00
      -50.00
      Goal:Increase Collaboration
      Alternative:Reface the Facade of Existing Annex
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      3
      3.00
      100.00
      Goal:Increase Collaboration
      Alternative:Make the Construction Annex 3 Stories Tall with Varying Roof Heights
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      2
      2.00
      89.00
      Goal:Increase Collaboration
      Alternative:Make the Construction Annex 2 Stories Tall with Flat Roof
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Increase Collaboration
      2.21%
      # of open spaces
      Open spaces encourage collaboration while closed spaces aren't as encouraging. Teamwork is a big part component of the re-design of the BC Annex.
    • Designer
      [X]
      Goal: Sustainable Construction
      Unit
      % of waste diverted from landfills
      Criterion
      75%
      Advantage
      91.00
      Goal:Sustainable Construction
      Alternative:Reface the Facade of Existing Annex
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      20%
      Advantage
      -10.00
      Goal:Sustainable Construction
      Alternative:Make the Construction Annex 3 Stories Tall with Varying Roof Heights
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      20%
      Advantage
      -10.00
      Goal:Sustainable Construction
      Alternative:Make the Construction Annex 2 Stories Tall with Flat Roof
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Sustainable Construction
      1.96%
      % of waste diverted from landfills
    • Designer
      [X]
      Goal: Increase productivity
      Unit
      % of facade that is open glass
      Criterion
      Increase productivity by providing more daylighting and views.
      100%
      Advantage
      100.00
      Goal:Increase productivity
      Alternative:Reface the Facade of Existing Annex
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      95%
      Advantage
      95.00
      Goal:Increase productivity
      Alternative:Make the Construction Annex 3 Stories Tall with Varying Roof Heights
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      100%
      Advantage
      100.00
      Goal:Increase productivity
      Alternative:Make the Construction Annex 2 Stories Tall with Flat Roof
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Increase productivity
      2.00%
      % of facade that is open glass
      Increase productivity by providing more daylighting and views.
    • Designer
      [X]
      Goal: Optimize Energy Performance
      Unit
      1 to 19 points based on a % improvement from 8% (1 point) to 44% (19 points)
      Criterion
      Demonstrate a percentage improvement in the proposed building rating compared with the baseline building performance rating.
      Attribute
      Advantage
      0.00
      Goal:Optimize Energy Performance
      Alternative:Reface the Facade of Existing Annex
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Attribute
      Advantage
      0.00
      Goal:Optimize Energy Performance
      Alternative:Make the Construction Annex 3 Stories Tall with Varying Roof Heights
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Attribute
      Advantage
      0.00
      Goal:Optimize Energy Performance
      Alternative:Make the Construction Annex 2 Stories Tall with Flat Roof
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Optimize Energy Performance
      4.18%
      1 to 19 points based on a % improvement from 8% (1 point) to 44% (19 points)
      Demonstrate a percentage improvement in the proposed building rating compared with the baseline building performance rating.
    • Designer
      [X]
      Goal: Building Reuse
      Unit
      1 point for 55% to 74% building re-use, 2 points for 75%-94% building resuse and 3 points for 95%-100% building reuse
      Criterion
      Consider reusing, previously-occupied building structures, envelopes, and other elements to extend the lifecycle of existing building stock, conserve resources, reduce waste and environmental impacts of new buildings as they relate to materials manufacturing and transport.
      Attribute
      Advantage
      0.00
      Goal:Building Reuse
      Alternative:Reface the Facade of Existing Annex
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Attribute
      Advantage
      0.00
      Goal:Building Reuse
      Alternative:Make the Construction Annex 3 Stories Tall with Varying Roof Heights
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Attribute
      Advantage
      0.00
      Goal:Building Reuse
      Alternative:Make the Construction Annex 2 Stories Tall with Flat Roof
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Building Reuse
      1.87%
      1 point for 55% to 74% building re-use, 2 points for 75%-94% building resuse and 3 points for 95%-100% building reuse
      Consider reusing, previously-occupied building structures, envelopes, and other elements to extend the lifecycle of existing building stock, conserve resources, reduce waste and environmental impacts of new buildings as they relate to materials manufacturing and transport.
    • Designer
      [X]
      Goal: Use Materials with Recycled Content
      Unit
      Criterion
      Use building materials that incorporate recycled content materials.
      Attribute
      Advantage
      0.00
      Goal:Use Materials with Recycled Content
      Alternative:Reface the Facade of Existing Annex
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Attribute
      Advantage
      0.00
      Goal:Use Materials with Recycled Content
      Alternative:Make the Construction Annex 3 Stories Tall with Varying Roof Heights
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Attribute
      Advantage
      0.00
      Goal:Use Materials with Recycled Content
      Alternative:Make the Construction Annex 2 Stories Tall with Flat Roof
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Use Materials with Recycled Content
      2.02%
      Use building materials that incorporate recycled content materials.
    • Designer
      [X]
      Goal: Make use of Regional Materials
      Unit
      10%, based on cost, of the total materials value. 10-19%=1 point, 20%+=2 points
      Criterion
      Use building materials and products that are extracted and manufactured within the region. Use building materials that have been harvested, recovered or extracted as well as manufactured within a specified distance of the project site.
      Attribute
      Advantage
      0.00
      Goal:Make use of Regional Materials
      Alternative:Reface the Facade of Existing Annex
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Attribute
      Advantage
      0.00
      Goal:Make use of Regional Materials
      Alternative:Make the Construction Annex 3 Stories Tall with Varying Roof Heights
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Attribute
      Advantage
      0.00
      Goal:Make use of Regional Materials
      Alternative:Make the Construction Annex 2 Stories Tall with Flat Roof
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Make use of Regional Materials
      2.27%
      10%, based on cost, of the total materials value. 10-19%=1 point, 20%+=2 points
      Use building materials and products that are extracted and manufactured within the region. Use building materials that have been harvested, recovered or extracted as well as manufactured within a specified distance of the project site.
    • Designer
      [X]
      Goal: Decrease Waste
      Unit
      percentage of materials that are diverted from landfills
      Criterion
      Attribute
      Advantage
      0.00
      Goal:Decrease Waste
      Alternative:Reface the Facade of Existing Annex
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Attribute
      Advantage
      0.00
      Goal:Decrease Waste
      Alternative:Make the Construction Annex 3 Stories Tall with Varying Roof Heights
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Attribute
      Advantage
      0.00
      Goal:Decrease Waste
      Alternative:Make the Construction Annex 2 Stories Tall with Flat Roof
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Decrease Waste
      2.31%
      percentage of materials that are diverted from landfills
    • Designer
      [X]
      Goal: Reduce Water Use
      Unit
      Water Reduction compared to the baseline. 30-34% reduction = 2 points, 35-40% reduction = 3 points, 40%+ reduction = 4 points
      Criterion
      To further increase water efficiency within buildings to reduce the burden on municipal water supply and wastewater systems.
      Attribute
      Advantage
      0.00
      Goal:Reduce Water Use
      Alternative:Reface the Facade of Existing Annex
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Attribute
      Advantage
      0.00
      Goal:Reduce Water Use
      Alternative:Make the Construction Annex 3 Stories Tall with Varying Roof Heights
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Attribute
      Advantage
      0.00
      Goal:Reduce Water Use
      Alternative:Make the Construction Annex 2 Stories Tall with Flat Roof
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Reduce Water Use
      3.22%
      Water Reduction compared to the baseline. 30-34% reduction = 2 points, 35-40% reduction = 3 points, 40%+ reduction = 4 points
      To further increase water efficiency within buildings to reduce the burden on municipal water supply and wastewater systems.
    • Designer
      [X]
      Goal: Lowest Initial Cost
      Unit
      $ per Sq. Ft
      Criterion
      Lowest initial cost of materials and building systems required for renovation.
      $2,533,442.15
      Advantage
      100.00
      Goal:Lowest Initial Cost
      Alternative:Reface the Facade of Existing Annex
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      $3,063,677.80
      Advantage
      0.00
      Goal:Lowest Initial Cost
      Alternative:Make the Construction Annex 3 Stories Tall with Varying Roof Heights
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      $3,258,792.99
      Advantage
      0.00
      Goal:Lowest Initial Cost
      Alternative:Make the Construction Annex 2 Stories Tall with Flat Roof
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Lowest Initial Cost
      10.00%
      $ per Sq. Ft
      Lowest initial cost of materials and building systems required for renovation.
    • Designer
      [X]
      Goal: Lowest Maintenance Costs
      Unit
      Maintenance cost per year
      Criterion
      Attribute
      Advantage
      0.00
      Goal:Lowest Maintenance Costs
      Alternative:Reface the Facade of Existing Annex
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Attribute
      Advantage
      0.00
      Goal:Lowest Maintenance Costs
      Alternative:Make the Construction Annex 3 Stories Tall with Varying Roof Heights
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Attribute
      Advantage
      0.00
      Goal:Lowest Maintenance Costs
      Alternative:Make the Construction Annex 2 Stories Tall with Flat Roof
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Lowest Maintenance Costs
      100.00%
      Maintenance cost per year
    • Designer
      [X]
      Goal: Greatest Energy Savings
      Unit
      % of Saved energy
      Criterion
      Attribute
      Advantage
      0.00
      Goal:Greatest Energy Savings
      Alternative:Reface the Facade of Existing Annex
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Attribute
      Advantage
      0.00
      Goal:Greatest Energy Savings
      Alternative:Make the Construction Annex 3 Stories Tall with Varying Roof Heights
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Attribute
      Advantage
      0.00
      Goal:Greatest Energy Savings
      Alternative:Make the Construction Annex 2 Stories Tall with Flat Roof
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Greatest Energy Savings
      100.00%
      % of Saved energy
  • Constraints
    • [X]
      Constraint: Affordability
      Additional information
      yes Info
      Constraint:Affordability
      Alternative:Reface the Facade of Existing Annex
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      yes Info
      Constraint:Affordability
      Alternative:Make the Construction Annex 3 Stories Tall with Varying Roof Heights
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      yes Info
      Constraint:Affordability
      Alternative:Make the Construction Annex 2 Stories Tall with Flat Roof
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Affordability
    • [X]
      Constraint: Building Codes
      Additional information
      yes Info
      Constraint:Building Codes
      Alternative:Reface the Facade of Existing Annex
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      yes Info
      Constraint:Building Codes
      Alternative:Make the Construction Annex 3 Stories Tall with Varying Roof Heights
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      yes Info
      Constraint:Building Codes
      Alternative:Make the Construction Annex 2 Stories Tall with Flat Roof
      Additional information:


      URL: http://
      Building Codes

Unable to compute Summary Chart due to missing Goal Weights.