Alternatives:
Protect
Winner
More Info
[X]
Alternative: Protect
Additional information
Protecting the port requires the construction of a storm barrier located south of the Port of Providence on Narragansett Bay. This barrier would need to be 25ft in height, similar to the current Fox Point barrier.

Considerations of impact on environment, economic, and society need also be included.

Relocate More Info
[X]
Alternative: Relocate
Additional information
Relocating port operations and may be a strategy to improve port business resilience. To do this, a less vulnerable location must be identified. Constraints that must be considered are:

- Surge elevation in relation to land elevation
- Available land space
- Available water space
- Access to 40ft navigation channel
- Access to rail and major interstate
- Amount of berthing space

Considerations of impact on environment, economy, and society need also be included.

Accomodate More Info
[X]
Alternative: Accomodate
Additional information
Accommodation entails altering individual properties and infrastructure in order to increase the resilience of individual firms and infrastructure. In aggregate the Port becomes more resilient. Accommodation strategies include:

- Elevating land
- Elevating buildings and infrastructure
- Elevating utilities
- Dry Flood Proofing
- Wet Flood Proofing
- Individual firm barriers and berms


Do Nothing More Info
[X]
Alternative: Do Nothing
Additional information
Do nothing involves leaving the port as is. Land uses, port operation, regulations, etc. will not change. Impacts as described during Part 1 of the workshop are a result of this resilience option.

Total Value:
18.71
18.71
13.41
8.79
1.16
Values:
0.0
Ensure post-hurricane business continuity for water front business More Info
4 1-5
3.36
Minimize huricane to damages to infrastructure and waterfront businesses More Info
4 1-5
3.24
Minimize hurricane-related environmental damage from port uses More Info
4 1-5
3.04
Build public support for hurricane resilience measures & port operations More Info
4 1-5
1.74
Minimize hazard insurance rates More Info
5 1-5
1.16
Foster port growth More Info
4 1-5
2.20
Protect human safety & critical lifelines More Info
5 1-5
3.98
Ensure post-hurricane business continuity for water front business More Info
4 1-5
3.36
Minimize huricane to damages to infrastructure and waterfront businesses More Info
3 1-5
2.16
Minimize hurricane-related environmental damage from port uses More Info
4 1-5
3.04
Minimize hazard insurance rates More Info
4 1-5
0.77
Foster port growth More Info
3 1-5
1.10
Protect human safety & critical lifelines More Info
4 1-5
2.99
Ensure post-hurricane business continuity for water front business More Info
3 1-5
1.68
Minimize huricane to damages to infrastructure and waterfront businesses More Info
2 1-5
1.08
Minimize hurricane-related environmental damage from port uses More Info
2 1-5
1.01
Build public support for hurricane resilience measures & port operations More Info
3 1-5
1.16
Minimize hazard insurance rates More Info
4 1-5
0.77
Foster port growth More Info
3 1-5
1.10
Protect human safety & critical lifelines More Info
3 1-5
1.99
Build public support for hurricane resilience measures & port operations More Info
3 1-5
1.16
Goal: Ensure post-hurricane business continuity for water front business
Alternative: Protect
Image:
URL: http://
Stakeholder Goal Weight Impact Value
PortProvReslience 001 0% 5.00 0.00
PortProvReslience 002 70% 5.00 3.50
PortProvReslience 003 90% 5.00 4.50
PortProvReslience 004 100% 5.00 5.00
PortProvReslience 005 90.07% 5.00 4.50
PortProvReslience 006 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 008 60% 5.00 3.00
PortProvResilience 009 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 010 90% 5.00 4.50
PortProvResilience 011 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 012 85.07% 5.00 4.25
PortProvResilience 013 85% 5.00 4.25
PortProvResilience 014 70.63% 5.00 3.53
PortProvResilience 016 30.9% 5.00 1.54
PortProvResilience 015 80.97% 5.00 4.05
PortProvResilience 017 24.06% 5.00 1.20
PortProvResilience 018 100% 5.00 5.00
PortProvResilience 019 15% 5.00 0.75
PortProvResilience 020 50.23% 5.00 2.51
PortProvResilience 021 61.24% 5.00 3.06
PortProvResilience 022 92.44% 5.00 4.62
PortProvResilience 023 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 025 100% 5.00 5.00
PortProvResilience 026 74.07% 5.00 3.70
PortProvResilience 027 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 028 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 029 10.58% 5.00 0.53
PortProvResilience 030 83.26% 5.00 4.16
PortProvResilience 031 80% 5.00 4.00
Total Value 77.18
Number Valid Stakeholders 23
Average Value 3.36
Goal: Minimize huricane to damages to infrastructure and waterfront businesses
Alternative: Protect
Image:
Stakeholder Goal Weight Impact Value
PortProvReslience 001 0% 5.00 0.00
PortProvReslience 002 100% 5.00 5.00
PortProvReslience 003 85% 5.00 4.25
PortProvReslience 004 90% 5.00 4.50
PortProvReslience 005 90.07% 5.00 4.50
PortProvReslience 006 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 008 60% 5.00 3.00
PortProvResilience 009 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 010 60% 5.00 3.00
PortProvResilience 011 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 012 71.24% 5.00 3.56
PortProvResilience 013 90% 5.00 4.50
PortProvResilience 014 70.01% 5.00 3.50
PortProvResilience 016 53.91% 5.00 2.70
PortProvResilience 015 80.31% 5.00 4.02
PortProvResilience 017 52.33% 5.00 2.62
PortProvResilience 018 75% 5.00 3.75
PortProvResilience 019 15% 5.00 0.75
PortProvResilience 020 50.56% 5.00 2.53
PortProvResilience 021 55.07% 5.00 2.75
PortProvResilience 022 78.01% 5.00 3.90
PortProvResilience 023 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 025 66.35% 5.00 3.32
PortProvResilience 026 78.4% 5.00 3.92
PortProvResilience 027 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 028 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 029 40.74% 5.00 2.04
PortProvResilience 030 53.09% 5.00 2.65
PortProvResilience 031 75% 5.00 3.75
Total Value 74.50
Number Valid Stakeholders 23
Average Value 3.24
Goal: Minimize hurricane-related environmental damage from port uses
Alternative: Protect
Image:
Stakeholder Goal Weight Impact Value
PortProvReslience 001 0% 5.00 0.00
PortProvReslience 002 60% 5.00 3.00
PortProvReslience 003 20% 5.00 1.00
PortProvReslience 004 50% 5.00 2.50
PortProvReslience 005 60.07% 5.00 3.00
PortProvReslience 006 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 008 10% 5.00 0.50
PortProvResilience 009 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 010 60% 5.00 3.00
PortProvResilience 011 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 012 84.24% 5.00 4.21
PortProvResilience 013 95% 5.00 4.75
PortProvResilience 014 89.94% 5.00 4.50
PortProvResilience 016 78.57% 5.00 3.93
PortProvResilience 015 80.49% 5.00 4.02
PortProvResilience 017 49.12% 5.00 2.46
PortProvResilience 018 75% 5.00 3.75
PortProvResilience 019 15% 5.00 0.75
PortProvResilience 020 34.74% 5.00 1.74
PortProvResilience 021 49.19% 5.00 2.46
PortProvResilience 022 78.23% 5.00 3.91
PortProvResilience 023 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 025 32.95% 5.00 1.65
PortProvResilience 026 90.07% 5.00 4.50
PortProvResilience 027 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 028 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 029 100% 5.00 5.00
PortProvResilience 030 94.08% 5.00 4.70
PortProvResilience 031 90% 5.00 4.50
Total Value 69.83
Number Valid Stakeholders 23
Average Value 3.04
Goal: Build public support for hurricane resilience measures & port operations
Alternative: Protect
Image:
Stakeholder Goal Weight Impact Value
PortProvReslience 001 0% 5.00 0.00
PortProvReslience 002 50% 5.00 2.50
PortProvReslience 003 10% 5.00 0.50
PortProvReslience 004 60% 5.00 3.00
PortProvReslience 005 60.24% 5.00 3.01
PortProvReslience 006 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 008 30% 5.00 1.50
PortProvResilience 009 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 010 20% 5.00 1.00
PortProvResilience 011 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 012 58.74% 5.00 2.94
PortProvResilience 013 60% 5.00 3.00
PortProvResilience 014 55.46% 5.00 2.77
PortProvResilience 016 20.74% 5.00 1.04
PortProvResilience 015 67.99% 5.00 3.40
PortProvResilience 017 33.52% 5.00 1.68
PortProvResilience 018 10% 5.00 0.50
PortProvResilience 019 15% 5.00 0.75
PortProvResilience 020 25.24% 5.00 1.26
PortProvResilience 021 43.89% 5.00 2.19
PortProvResilience 022 33.38% 5.00 1.67
PortProvResilience 023 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 025 32.95% 5.00 1.65
PortProvResilience 026 49.91% 5.00 2.50
PortProvResilience 027 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 028 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 029 10.91% 5.00 0.55
PortProvResilience 030 21.71% 5.00 1.09
PortProvResilience 031 30% 5.00 1.50
Total Value 39.98
Number Valid Stakeholders 23
Average Value 1.74
Goal: Minimize hazard insurance rates
Alternative: Protect
Image:
Stakeholder Goal Weight Impact Value
PortProvReslience 001 0% 5.00 0.00
PortProvReslience 002 10% 5.00 0.50
PortProvReslience 003 10% 5.00 0.50
PortProvReslience 004 20% 5.00 1.00
PortProvReslience 005 60.24% 5.00 3.01
PortProvReslience 006 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 008 10% 5.00 0.50
PortProvResilience 009 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 010 20% 5.00 1.00
PortProvResilience 011 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 012 42.41% 5.00 2.12
PortProvResilience 013 30% 5.00 1.50
PortProvResilience 014 19.58% 5.00 0.98
PortProvResilience 016 7.57% 5.00 0.38
PortProvResilience 015 68.31% 5.00 3.42
PortProvResilience 017 15.58% 5.00 0.78
PortProvResilience 018 20% 5.00 1.00
PortProvResilience 019 20% 5.00 1.00
PortProvResilience 020 20.41% 5.00 1.02
PortProvResilience 021 14.9% 5.00 0.74
PortProvResilience 022 5.81% 5.00 0.29
PortProvResilience 023 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 025 0% 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 026 8.75% 5.00 0.44
PortProvResilience 027 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 028 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 029 0% 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 030 100% 5.00 5.00
PortProvResilience 031 30% 5.00 1.50
Total Value 26.68
Number Valid Stakeholders 23
Average Value 1.16
Goal: Foster port growth
Alternative: Protect
Image:
Stakeholder Goal Weight Impact Value
PortProvReslience 001 0% 5.00 0.00
PortProvReslience 002 25% 5.00 1.25
PortProvReslience 003 100% 5.00 5.00
PortProvReslience 004 70% 5.00 3.50
PortProvReslience 005 20.08% 5.00 1.00
PortProvReslience 006 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 008 80% 5.00 4.00
PortProvResilience 009 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 010 20% 5.00 1.00
PortProvResilience 011 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 012 85.41% 5.00 4.27
PortProvResilience 013 20% 5.00 1.00
PortProvResilience 014 55.31% 5.00 2.77
PortProvResilience 016 40.07% 5.00 2.00
PortProvResilience 015 30.66% 5.00 1.53
PortProvResilience 017 31.75% 5.00 1.59
PortProvResilience 018 75% 5.00 3.75
PortProvResilience 019 10% 5.00 0.50
PortProvResilience 020 20.58% 5.00 1.03
PortProvResilience 021 10.74% 5.00 0.54
PortProvResilience 022 87.56% 5.00 4.38
PortProvResilience 023 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 025 90.76% 5.00 4.54
PortProvResilience 026 23.58% 5.00 1.18
PortProvResilience 027 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 028 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 029 0% 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 030 99.48% 5.00 4.97
PortProvResilience 031 15% 5.00 0.75
Total Value 50.55
Number Valid Stakeholders 23
Average Value 2.20
Goal: Protect human safety & critical lifelines
Alternative: Protect
Image:
Stakeholder Goal Weight Impact Value
PortProvReslience 001 0% 5.00 0.00
PortProvReslience 002 100% 5.00 5.00
PortProvReslience 003 90% 5.00 4.50
PortProvReslience 004 50% 5.00 2.50
PortProvReslience 005 90.07% 5.00 4.50
PortProvReslience 006 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 008 100% 5.00 5.00
PortProvResilience 009 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 010 100% 5.00 5.00
PortProvResilience 011 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 012 99.99% 5.00 5.00
PortProvResilience 013 100% 5.00 5.00
PortProvResilience 014 100% 5.00 5.00
PortProvResilience 016 99.99% 5.00 5.00
PortProvResilience 015 90.98% 5.00 4.55
PortProvResilience 017 100% 5.00 5.00
PortProvResilience 018 80% 5.00 4.00
PortProvResilience 019 10% 5.00 0.50
PortProvResilience 020 40.91% 5.00 2.05
PortProvResilience 021 68.91% 5.00 3.45
PortProvResilience 022 100% 5.00 5.00
PortProvResilience 023 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 025 67.72% 5.00 3.39
PortProvResilience 026 99.99% 5.00 5.00
PortProvResilience 027 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 028 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 029 100% 5.00 5.00
PortProvResilience 030 52.75% 5.00 2.64
PortProvResilience 031 90% 5.00 4.50
Total Value 91.57
Number Valid Stakeholders 23
Average Value 3.98
Goal: Ensure post-hurricane business continuity for water front business
Alternative: Relocate
Image:
Stakeholder Goal Weight Impact Value
PortProvReslience 001 0% 5.00 0.00
PortProvReslience 002 70% 5.00 3.50
PortProvReslience 003 90% 5.00 4.50
PortProvReslience 004 100% 5.00 5.00
PortProvReslience 005 90.07% 5.00 4.50
PortProvReslience 006 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 008 60% 5.00 3.00
PortProvResilience 009 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 010 90% 5.00 4.50
PortProvResilience 011 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 012 85.07% 5.00 4.25
PortProvResilience 013 85% 5.00 4.25
PortProvResilience 014 70.63% 5.00 3.53
PortProvResilience 016 30.9% 5.00 1.54
PortProvResilience 015 80.97% 5.00 4.05
PortProvResilience 017 24.06% 5.00 1.20
PortProvResilience 018 100% 5.00 5.00
PortProvResilience 019 15% 5.00 0.75
PortProvResilience 020 50.23% 5.00 2.51
PortProvResilience 021 61.24% 5.00 3.06
PortProvResilience 022 92.44% 5.00 4.62
PortProvResilience 023 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 025 100% 5.00 5.00
PortProvResilience 026 74.07% 5.00 3.70
PortProvResilience 027 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 028 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 029 10.58% 5.00 0.53
PortProvResilience 030 83.26% 5.00 4.16
PortProvResilience 031 80% 5.00 4.00
Total Value 77.18
Number Valid Stakeholders 23
Average Value 3.36
Goal: Minimize huricane to damages to infrastructure and waterfront businesses
Alternative: Relocate
Image:
Stakeholder Goal Weight Impact Value
PortProvReslience 001 0% 3.33 0.00
PortProvReslience 002 100% 3.33 3.33
PortProvReslience 003 85% 3.33 2.83
PortProvReslience 004 90% 3.33 3.00
PortProvReslience 005 90.07% 3.33 3.00
PortProvReslience 006 No Value Set 3.33 0.00
PortProvResilience 008 60% 3.33 2.00
PortProvResilience 009 No Value Set 3.33 0.00
PortProvResilience 010 60% 3.33 2.00
PortProvResilience 011 No Value Set 3.33 0.00
PortProvResilience 012 71.24% 3.33 2.37
PortProvResilience 013 90% 3.33 3.00
PortProvResilience 014 70.01% 3.33 2.33
PortProvResilience 016 53.91% 3.33 1.80
PortProvResilience 015 80.31% 3.33 2.68
PortProvResilience 017 52.33% 3.33 1.74
PortProvResilience 018 75% 3.33 2.50
PortProvResilience 019 15% 3.33 0.50
PortProvResilience 020 50.56% 3.33 1.69
PortProvResilience 021 55.07% 3.33 1.84
PortProvResilience 022 78.01% 3.33 2.60
PortProvResilience 023 No Value Set 3.33 0.00
PortProvResilience 025 66.35% 3.33 2.21
PortProvResilience 026 78.4% 3.33 2.61
PortProvResilience 027 No Value Set 3.33 0.00
PortProvResilience 028 No Value Set 3.33 0.00
PortProvResilience 029 40.74% 3.33 1.36
PortProvResilience 030 53.09% 3.33 1.77
PortProvResilience 031 75% 3.33 2.50
Total Value 49.67
Number Valid Stakeholders 23
Average Value 2.16
Goal: Minimize hurricane-related environmental damage from port uses
Alternative: Relocate
Image:
Stakeholder Goal Weight Impact Value
PortProvReslience 001 0% 5.00 0.00
PortProvReslience 002 60% 5.00 3.00
PortProvReslience 003 20% 5.00 1.00
PortProvReslience 004 50% 5.00 2.50
PortProvReslience 005 60.07% 5.00 3.00
PortProvReslience 006 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 008 10% 5.00 0.50
PortProvResilience 009 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 010 60% 5.00 3.00
PortProvResilience 011 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 012 84.24% 5.00 4.21
PortProvResilience 013 95% 5.00 4.75
PortProvResilience 014 89.94% 5.00 4.50
PortProvResilience 016 78.57% 5.00 3.93
PortProvResilience 015 80.49% 5.00 4.02
PortProvResilience 017 49.12% 5.00 2.46
PortProvResilience 018 75% 5.00 3.75
PortProvResilience 019 15% 5.00 0.75
PortProvResilience 020 34.74% 5.00 1.74
PortProvResilience 021 49.19% 5.00 2.46
PortProvResilience 022 78.23% 5.00 3.91
PortProvResilience 023 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 025 32.95% 5.00 1.65
PortProvResilience 026 90.07% 5.00 4.50
PortProvResilience 027 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 028 No Value Set 5.00 0.00
PortProvResilience 029 100% 5.00 5.00
PortProvResilience 030 94.08% 5.00 4.70
PortProvResilience 031 90% 5.00 4.50
Total Value 69.83
Number Valid Stakeholders 23
Average Value 3.04
Goal: Minimize hazard insurance rates
Alternative: Relocate
Image:
Stakeholder Goal Weight Impact Value
PortProvReslience 001 0% 3.33 0.00
PortProvReslience 002 10% 3.33 0.33
PortProvReslience 003 10% 3.33 0.33
PortProvReslience 004 20% 3.33 0.67
PortProvReslience 005 60.24% 3.33 2.01
PortProvReslience 006 No Value Set 3.33 0.00
PortProvResilience 008 10% 3.33 0.33
PortProvResilience 009 No Value Set 3.33 0.00
PortProvResilience 010 20% 3.33 0.67
PortProvResilience 011 No Value Set 3.33 0.00
PortProvResilience 012 42.41% 3.33 1.41
PortProvResilience 013 30% 3.33 1.00
PortProvResilience 014 19.58% 3.33 0.65
PortProvResilience 016 7.57% 3.33 0.25
PortProvResilience 015 68.31% 3.33 2.28
PortProvResilience 017 15.58% 3.33 0.52
PortProvResilience 018 20% 3.33 0.67
PortProvResilience 019 20% 3.33 0.67
PortProvResilience 020 20.41% 3.33 0.68
PortProvResilience 021 14.9% 3.33 0.50
PortProvResilience 022 5.81% 3.33 0.19
PortProvResilience 023 No Value Set 3.33 0.00
PortProvResilience 025 0% 3.33 0.00
PortProvResilience 026 8.75% 3.33 0.29
PortProvResilience 027 No Value Set 3.33 0.00
PortProvResilience 028 No Value Set 3.33 0.00
PortProvResilience 029 0% 3.33 0.00
PortProvResilience 030 100% 3.33 3.33
PortProvResilience 031 30% 3.33 1.00
Total Value 17.79
Number Valid Stakeholders 23
Average Value 0.77
Goal: Foster port growth
Alternative: Relocate
Image:
Stakeholder Goal Weight Impact Value
PortProvReslience 001 0% 2.50 0.00
PortProvReslience 002 25% 2.50 0.62
PortProvReslience 003 100% 2.50 2.50
PortProvReslience 004 70% 2.50 1.75
PortProvReslience 005 20.08% 2.50 0.50
PortProvReslience 006 No Value Set 2.50 0.00
PortProvResilience 008 80% 2.50 2.00
PortProvResilience 009 No Value Set 2.50 0.00
PortProvResilience 010 20% 2.50 0.50
PortProvResilience 011 No Value Set 2.50 0.00
PortProvResilience 012 85.41% 2.50 2.14
PortProvResilience 013 20% 2.50 0.50
PortProvResilience 014 55.31% 2.50 1.38
PortProvResilience 016 40.07% 2.50 1.00
PortProvResilience 015 30.66% 2.50 0.77
PortProvResilience 017 31.75% 2.50 0.79
PortProvResilience 018 75% 2.50 1.88
PortProvResilience 019 10% 2.50 0.25
PortProvResilience 020 20.58% 2.50 0.51
PortProvResilience 021 10.74% 2.50 0.27
PortProvResilience 022 87.56% 2.50 2.19
PortProvResilience 023 No Value Set 2.50 0.00
PortProvResilience 025 90.76% 2.50 2.27
PortProvResilience 026 23.58% 2.50 0.59
PortProvResilience 027 No Value Set 2.50 0.00
PortProvResilience 028 No Value Set 2.50 0.00
PortProvResilience 029 0% 2.50 0.00
PortProvResilience 030 99.48% 2.50 2.49
PortProvResilience 031 15% 2.50 0.38
Total Value 25.27
Number Valid Stakeholders 23
Average Value 1.10
Goal: Protect human safety & critical lifelines
Alternative: Relocate
Image:
Stakeholder Goal Weight Impact Value
PortProvReslience 001 0% 3.75 0.00
PortProvReslience 002 100% 3.75 3.75
PortProvReslience 003 90% 3.75 3.38
PortProvReslience 004 50% 3.75 1.88
PortProvReslience 005 90.07% 3.75 3.38
PortProvReslience 006 No Value Set 3.75 0.00
PortProvResilience 008 100% 3.75 3.75
PortProvResilience 009 No Value Set 3.75 0.00
PortProvResilience 010 100% 3.75 3.75
PortProvResilience 011 No Value Set 3.75 0.00
PortProvResilience 012 99.99% 3.75 3.75
PortProvResilience 013 100% 3.75 3.75
PortProvResilience 014 100% 3.75 3.75
PortProvResilience 016 99.99% 3.75 3.75
PortProvResilience 015 90.98% 3.75 3.41
PortProvResilience 017 100% 3.75 3.75
PortProvResilience 018 80% 3.75 3.00
PortProvResilience 019 10% 3.75 0.38
PortProvResilience 020 40.91% 3.75 1.53
PortProvResilience 021 68.91% 3.75 2.58
PortProvResilience 022 100% 3.75 3.75
PortProvResilience 023 No Value Set 3.75 0.00
PortProvResilience 025 67.72% 3.75 2.54
PortProvResilience 026 99.99% 3.75 3.75
PortProvResilience 027 No Value Set 3.75 0.00
PortProvResilience 028 No Value Set 3.75 0.00
PortProvResilience 029 100% 3.75 3.75
PortProvResilience 030 52.75% 3.75 1.98
PortProvResilience 031 90% 3.75 3.38
Total Value 68.67
Number Valid Stakeholders 23
Average Value 2.99
Goal: Ensure post-hurricane business continuity for water front business
Alternative: Accomodate
Image:
Stakeholder Goal Weight Impact Value
PortProvReslience 001 0% 2.50 0.00
PortProvReslience 002 70% 2.50 1.75
PortProvReslience 003 90% 2.50 2.25
PortProvReslience 004 100% 2.50 2.50
PortProvReslience 005 90.07% 2.50 2.25
PortProvReslience 006 No Value Set 2.50 0.00
PortProvResilience 008 60% 2.50 1.50
PortProvResilience 009 No Value Set 2.50 0.00
PortProvResilience 010 90% 2.50 2.25
PortProvResilience 011 No Value Set 2.50 0.00
PortProvResilience 012 85.07% 2.50 2.13
PortProvResilience 013 85% 2.50 2.12
PortProvResilience 014 70.63% 2.50 1.77
PortProvResilience 016 30.9% 2.50 0.77
PortProvResilience 015 80.97% 2.50 2.02
PortProvResilience 017 24.06% 2.50 0.60
PortProvResilience 018 100% 2.50 2.50
PortProvResilience 019 15% 2.50 0.38
PortProvResilience 020 50.23% 2.50 1.26
PortProvResilience 021 61.24% 2.50 1.53
PortProvResilience 022 92.44% 2.50 2.31
PortProvResilience 023 No Value Set 2.50 0.00
PortProvResilience 025 100% 2.50 2.50
PortProvResilience 026 74.07% 2.50 1.85
PortProvResilience 027 No Value Set 2.50 0.00
PortProvResilience 028 No Value Set 2.50 0.00
PortProvResilience 029 10.58% 2.50 0.26
PortProvResilience 030 83.26% 2.50 2.08
PortProvResilience 031 80% 2.50 2.00
Total Value 38.59
Number Valid Stakeholders 23
Average Value 1.68
Goal: Minimize huricane to damages to infrastructure and waterfront businesses
Alternative: Accomodate
Image:
Stakeholder Goal Weight Impact Value
PortProvReslience 001 0% 1.67 0.00
PortProvReslience 002 100% 1.67 1.67
PortProvReslience 003 85% 1.67 1.42
PortProvReslience 004 90% 1.67 1.50
PortProvReslience 005 90.07% 1.67 1.50
PortProvReslience 006 No Value Set 1.67 0.00
PortProvResilience 008 60% 1.67 1.00
PortProvResilience 009 No Value Set 1.67 0.00
PortProvResilience 010 60% 1.67 1.00
PortProvResilience 011 No Value Set 1.67 0.00
PortProvResilience 012 71.24% 1.67 1.19
PortProvResilience 013 90% 1.67 1.50
PortProvResilience 014 70.01% 1.67 1.17
PortProvResilience 016 53.91% 1.67 0.90
PortProvResilience 015 80.31% 1.67 1.34
PortProvResilience 017 52.33% 1.67 0.87
PortProvResilience 018 75% 1.67 1.25
PortProvResilience 019 15% 1.67 0.25
PortProvResilience 020 50.56% 1.67 0.84
PortProvResilience 021 55.07% 1.67 0.92
PortProvResilience 022 78.01% 1.67 1.30
PortProvResilience 023 No Value Set 1.67 0.00
PortProvResilience 025 66.35% 1.67 1.11
PortProvResilience 026 78.4% 1.67 1.31
PortProvResilience 027 No Value Set 1.67 0.00
PortProvResilience 028 No Value Set 1.67 0.00
PortProvResilience 029 40.74% 1.67 0.68
PortProvResilience 030 53.09% 1.67 0.88
PortProvResilience 031 75% 1.67 1.25
Total Value 24.83
Number Valid Stakeholders 23
Average Value 1.08
Goal: Minimize hurricane-related environmental damage from port uses
Alternative: Accomodate
Image:
Stakeholder Goal Weight Impact Value
PortProvReslience 001 0% 1.67 0.00
PortProvReslience 002 60% 1.67 1.00
PortProvReslience 003 20% 1.67 0.33
PortProvReslience 004 50% 1.67 0.83
PortProvReslience 005 60.07% 1.67 1.00
PortProvReslience 006 No Value Set 1.67 0.00
PortProvResilience 008 10% 1.67 0.17
PortProvResilience 009 No Value Set 1.67 0.00
PortProvResilience 010 60% 1.67 1.00
PortProvResilience 011 No Value Set 1.67 0.00
PortProvResilience 012 84.24% 1.67 1.40
PortProvResilience 013 95% 1.67 1.58
PortProvResilience 014 89.94% 1.67 1.50
PortProvResilience 016 78.57% 1.67 1.31
PortProvResilience 015 80.49% 1.67 1.34
PortProvResilience 017 49.12% 1.67 0.82
PortProvResilience 018 75% 1.67 1.25
PortProvResilience 019 15% 1.67 0.25
PortProvResilience 020 34.74% 1.67 0.58
PortProvResilience 021 49.19% 1.67 0.82
PortProvResilience 022 78.23% 1.67 1.30
PortProvResilience 023 No Value Set 1.67 0.00
PortProvResilience 025 32.95% 1.67 0.55
PortProvResilience 026 90.07% 1.67 1.50
PortProvResilience 027 No Value Set 1.67 0.00
PortProvResilience 028 No Value Set 1.67 0.00
PortProvResilience 029 100% 1.67 1.67
PortProvResilience 030 94.08% 1.67 1.57
PortProvResilience 031 90% 1.67 1.50
Total Value 23.28
Number Valid Stakeholders 23
Average Value 1.01
Goal: Build public support for hurricane resilience measures & port operations
Alternative: Accomodate
Image:
Stakeholder Goal Weight Impact Value
PortProvReslience 001 0% 3.33 0.00
PortProvReslience 002 50% 3.33 1.67
PortProvReslience 003 10% 3.33 0.33
PortProvReslience 004 60% 3.33 2.00
PortProvReslience 005 60.24% 3.33 2.01
PortProvReslience 006 No Value Set 3.33 0.00
PortProvResilience 008 30% 3.33 1.00
PortProvResilience 009 No Value Set 3.33 0.00
PortProvResilience 010 20% 3.33 0.67
PortProvResilience 011 No Value Set 3.33 0.00
PortProvResilience 012 58.74% 3.33 1.96
PortProvResilience 013 60% 3.33 2.00
PortProvResilience 014 55.46% 3.33 1.85
PortProvResilience 016 20.74% 3.33 0.69
PortProvResilience 015 67.99% 3.33 2.27
PortProvResilience 017 33.52% 3.33 1.12
PortProvResilience 018 10% 3.33 0.33
PortProvResilience 019 15% 3.33 0.50
PortProvResilience 020 25.24% 3.33 0.84
PortProvResilience 021 43.89% 3.33 1.46
PortProvResilience 022 33.38% 3.33 1.11
PortProvResilience 023 No Value Set 3.33 0.00
PortProvResilience 025 32.95% 3.33 1.10
PortProvResilience 026 49.91% 3.33 1.66
PortProvResilience 027 No Value Set 3.33 0.00
PortProvResilience 028 No Value Set 3.33 0.00
PortProvResilience 029 10.91% 3.33 0.36
PortProvResilience 030 21.71% 3.33 0.72
PortProvResilience 031 30% 3.33 1.00
Total Value 26.66
Number Valid Stakeholders 23
Average Value 1.16
Goal: Minimize hazard insurance rates
Alternative: Accomodate
Image:
Stakeholder Goal Weight Impact Value
PortProvReslience 001 0% 3.33 0.00
PortProvReslience 002 10% 3.33 0.33
PortProvReslience 003 10% 3.33 0.33
PortProvReslience 004 20% 3.33 0.67
PortProvReslience 005 60.24% 3.33 2.01
PortProvReslience 006 No Value Set 3.33 0.00
PortProvResilience 008 10% 3.33 0.33
PortProvResilience 009 No Value Set 3.33 0.00
PortProvResilience 010 20% 3.33 0.67
PortProvResilience 011 No Value Set 3.33 0.00
PortProvResilience 012 42.41% 3.33 1.41
PortProvResilience 013 30% 3.33 1.00
PortProvResilience 014 19.58% 3.33 0.65
PortProvResilience 016 7.57% 3.33 0.25
PortProvResilience 015 68.31% 3.33 2.28
PortProvResilience 017 15.58% 3.33 0.52
PortProvResilience 018 20% 3.33 0.67
PortProvResilience 019 20% 3.33 0.67
PortProvResilience 020 20.41% 3.33 0.68
PortProvResilience 021 14.9% 3.33 0.50
PortProvResilience 022 5.81% 3.33 0.19
PortProvResilience 023 No Value Set 3.33 0.00
PortProvResilience 025 0% 3.33 0.00
PortProvResilience 026 8.75% 3.33 0.29
PortProvResilience 027 No Value Set 3.33 0.00
PortProvResilience 028 No Value Set 3.33 0.00
PortProvResilience 029 0% 3.33 0.00
PortProvResilience 030 100% 3.33 3.33
PortProvResilience 031 30% 3.33 1.00
Total Value 17.79
Number Valid Stakeholders 23
Average Value 0.77
Goal: Foster port growth
Alternative: Accomodate
Image:
Stakeholder Goal Weight Impact Value
PortProvReslience 001 0% 2.50 0.00
PortProvReslience 002 25% 2.50 0.62
PortProvReslience 003 100% 2.50 2.50
PortProvReslience 004 70% 2.50 1.75
PortProvReslience 005 20.08% 2.50 0.50
PortProvReslience 006 No Value Set 2.50 0.00
PortProvResilience 008 80% 2.50 2.00
PortProvResilience 009 No Value Set 2.50 0.00
PortProvResilience 010 20% 2.50 0.50
PortProvResilience 011 No Value Set 2.50 0.00
PortProvResilience 012 85.41% 2.50 2.14
PortProvResilience 013 20% 2.50 0.50
PortProvResilience 014 55.31% 2.50 1.38
PortProvResilience 016 40.07% 2.50 1.00
PortProvResilience 015 30.66% 2.50 0.77
PortProvResilience 017 31.75% 2.50 0.79
PortProvResilience 018 75% 2.50 1.88
PortProvResilience 019 10% 2.50 0.25
PortProvResilience 020 20.58% 2.50 0.51
PortProvResilience 021 10.74% 2.50 0.27
PortProvResilience 022 87.56% 2.50 2.19
PortProvResilience 023 No Value Set 2.50 0.00
PortProvResilience 025 90.76% 2.50 2.27
PortProvResilience 026 23.58% 2.50 0.59
PortProvResilience 027 No Value Set 2.50 0.00
PortProvResilience 028 No Value Set 2.50 0.00
PortProvResilience 029 0% 2.50 0.00
PortProvResilience 030 99.48% 2.50 2.49
PortProvResilience 031 15% 2.50 0.38
Total Value 25.27
Number Valid Stakeholders 23
Average Value 1.10
Goal: Protect human safety & critical lifelines
Alternative: Accomodate
Image:
Stakeholder Goal Weight Impact Value
PortProvReslience 001 0% 2.50 0.00
PortProvReslience 002 100% 2.50 2.50
PortProvReslience 003 90% 2.50 2.25
PortProvReslience 004 50% 2.50 1.25
PortProvReslience 005 90.07% 2.50 2.25
PortProvReslience 006 No Value Set 2.50 0.00
PortProvResilience 008 100% 2.50 2.50
PortProvResilience 009 No Value Set 2.50 0.00
PortProvResilience 010 100% 2.50 2.50
PortProvResilience 011 No Value Set 2.50 0.00
PortProvResilience 012 99.99% 2.50 2.50
PortProvResilience 013 100% 2.50 2.50
PortProvResilience 014 100% 2.50 2.50
PortProvResilience 016 99.99% 2.50 2.50
PortProvResilience 015 90.98% 2.50 2.27
PortProvResilience 017 100% 2.50 2.50
PortProvResilience 018 80% 2.50 2.00
PortProvResilience 019 10% 2.50 0.25
PortProvResilience 020 40.91% 2.50 1.02
PortProvResilience 021 68.91% 2.50 1.72
PortProvResilience 022 100% 2.50 2.50
PortProvResilience 023 No Value Set 2.50 0.00
PortProvResilience 025 67.72% 2.50 1.69
PortProvResilience 026 99.99% 2.50 2.50
PortProvResilience 027 No Value Set 2.50 0.00
PortProvResilience 028 No Value Set 2.50 0.00
PortProvResilience 029 100% 2.50 2.50
PortProvResilience 030 52.75% 2.50 1.32
PortProvResilience 031 90% 2.50 2.25
Total Value 45.78
Number Valid Stakeholders 23
Average Value 1.99
Goal: Build public support for hurricane resilience measures & port operations
Alternative: Do Nothing
Image:
Stakeholder Goal Weight Impact Value
PortProvReslience 001 0% 3.33 0.00
PortProvReslience 002 50% 3.33 1.67
PortProvReslience 003 10% 3.33 0.33
PortProvReslience 004 60% 3.33 2.00
PortProvReslience 005 60.24% 3.33 2.01
PortProvReslience 006 No Value Set 3.33 0.00
PortProvResilience 008 30% 3.33 1.00
PortProvResilience 009 No Value Set 3.33 0.00
PortProvResilience 010 20% 3.33 0.67
PortProvResilience 011 No Value Set 3.33 0.00
PortProvResilience 012 58.74% 3.33 1.96
PortProvResilience 013 60% 3.33 2.00
PortProvResilience 014 55.46% 3.33 1.85
PortProvResilience 016 20.74% 3.33 0.69
PortProvResilience 015 67.99% 3.33 2.27
PortProvResilience 017 33.52% 3.33 1.12
PortProvResilience 018 10% 3.33 0.33
PortProvResilience 019 15% 3.33 0.50
PortProvResilience 020 25.24% 3.33 0.84
PortProvResilience 021 43.89% 3.33 1.46
PortProvResilience 022 33.38% 3.33 1.11
PortProvResilience 023 No Value Set 3.33 0.00
PortProvResilience 025 32.95% 3.33 1.10
PortProvResilience 026 49.91% 3.33 1.66
PortProvResilience 027 No Value Set 3.33 0.00
PortProvResilience 028 No Value Set 3.33 0.00
PortProvResilience 029 10.91% 3.33 0.36
PortProvResilience 030 21.71% 3.33 0.72
PortProvResilience 031 30% 3.33 1.00
Total Value 26.66
Number Valid Stakeholders 23
Average Value 1.16
Stakeholders
PortProvReslience 001
PortProvReslience 002
PortProvReslience 003
PortProvReslience 004
PortProvReslience 005
PortProvReslience 006
PortProvResilience 008
PortProvResilience 009
PortProvResilience 010
PortProvResilience 011
PortProvResilience 012
PortProvResilience 013
PortProvResilience 014
PortProvResilience 015
PortProvResilience 016
PortProvResilience 017
PortProvResilience 018
PortProvResilience 019
PortProvResilience 020
PortProvResilience 021
PortProvResilience 022
PortProvResilience 023
PortProvResilience 025
PortProvResilience 026
PortProvResilience 028
PortProvResilience 029
PortProvResilience 030
PortProvResilience 031
PortProvResilience 027
Designers
John Haymaker
Austin Becker
Eric Kretsch